Injury Updates

Status
Not open for further replies.
ninjamonkey said:
This could very well be an injury that has no relation to him just returning from his other injury but regardless, our entire medical teams needs a lengthy review. His return has been mis-managed and its not the first time that’s happened. we get an unnatural number of players injuring themselves very shortly after a prior injury, sometimes reoccurring, sometimes unrelated, and we seem to get a lot more muscular injuries than other teams. It may be it’s entirely coincidental and just unlucky or we may just have a bunch of injury prone players but the club has to at least question themselves and be looking for better methods
Click to expand...

I would fire the whole medical team, physios, the lot.

start agin, decide what ‘first class’ looks like....and buy in the talent.
 
DenisLawBackHeel74 said:
I would fire the whole medical team, physios, the lot.

start agin, decide what ‘first class’ looks like....and buy in the talent.
Click to expand...

Get Eva in...

eva-carneiro-604524740.jpg



eva.jpg
 
Easy said:
Mismanagement again. Shouldn’t have played Leicester. 3 starts in a week is just too much for someone coming back from such a long injury loss, no he didn’t play the full 90 min in the previous 2 games but that doesn’t matter.

should have got 15-20 minutes from the bench vs Leicester max. He was rushed back.
Click to expand...

with hindsight a fair comment , with all the technology and science involved with players fitness levels , surprising that he has been risked. Laporte is needed for the last ten/twelve games , that is the business end when the trophies are handed out.
 
I don't think the physios have got a clue how to go about treating injuries, other teams don't seem to have any problems
 
Easy said:
Mismanagement again. Shouldn’t have played Leicester. 3 starts in a week is just too much for someone coming back from such a long injury loss, no he didn’t play the full 90 min in the previous 2 games but that doesn’t matter.

should have got 15-20 minutes from the bench vs Leicester max. He was rushed back.
Click to expand...

I think most of us was surprised he played for 70 mins in his come back game. I think that's pretty shocking from our medical team to be honest. He even waved to the bench to tell them he's time was up.
 
Akpowell said:
I don't think the physios have got a clue how to go about treating injuries, other teams don't seem to have any problems
Click to expand...
they are not geting players out for 8/9 months at a time,in the past 3yrs we have had 3 ACL's 2 other knee injuries as well,dr cugat does a good job fixing then but the rehab is different for everyone,it takes as long as it takes
 
Akpowell said:
I don't think the physios have got a clue how to go about treating injuries, other teams don't seem to have any problems
Click to expand...
At one point Newcastle and Bournemouth only had 16 of their 25 man squads to choose from. In one game Newcastle had 7 of what would be their first choice 11 out injured.

United have had more injuries than we have all season. When they beat us at our place they had more key players out than we did.

We’ve done just about above average for injuries this season. Yet because we haven’t done as well results-wise everyone looks for excuses and injuries is an easy one to hold on to. It stops people admitting we’re not good enough.
 
Psychedelic Casual said:
At one point Newcastle and Bournemouth only had 16 of their 25 man squads to choose from. In one game Newcastle had 7 of what would be their first choice 11 out injured.

United have had more injuries than we have all season. When they beat us at our place they had more key players out than we did.

We’ve done just about above average for injuries this season. Yet because we haven’t done as well results-wise everyone looks for excuses and injuries is an easy one to hold on to. It stops people admitting we’re not good enough.
Click to expand...
So we're rubbish, then?
 
Psychedelic Casual said:
At one point Newcastle and Bournemouth only had 16 of their 25 man squads to choose from. In one game Newcastle had 7 of what would be their first choice 11 out injured.

United have had more injuries than we have all season. When they beat us at our place they had more key players out than we did.

We’ve done just about above average for injuries this season. Yet because we haven’t done as well results-wise everyone looks for excuses and injuries is an easy one to hold on to. It stops people admitting we’re not good enough.
Click to expand...
I agree and disagree.

We have a better injury record than most but we were very reliant on Laporte and losing him was a killer blow.
 
Hamstring after knee is very common. Especially if they used the hammy to fix the knee. (Did eith mine)
 
hobbsisablue said:
Ok...so no other Premier League teams have any injuries? Wow, that's amazing.
Click to expand...

I don't think the problem is with the major injury necessarily occuring - that happens.

The problem is what seems to be consistent issues once they've made a full recovery from that injury, extending the timeout from anywhere between 1-3 months cumulatively. That's completing negating the advantage of getting to bring them back early, and even making it worse.

People seem to think it's normal - it's not. Especially not with the medical care and analysis that these guys get.
 
ws01 said:
I don't think the problem is with the major injury necessarily occuring - that happens.

The problem is what seems to be consistent issues once they've made a full recovery from that injury, extending the timeout from anywhere between 1-3 months cumulatively. That's completing negating the advantage of getting to bring them back early, and even making it worse.

People seem to think it's normal - it's not. Especially not with the medical care and analysis that these guys get.
Click to expand...
The body works at it's own pace whatever you do
 
jimmygrimblesboots said:
with hindsight a fair comment , with all the technology and science involved with players fitness levels , surprising that he has been risked. Laporte is needed for the last ten/twelve games , that is the business end when the trophies are handed out.
Click to expand...

I was genuinely shocked to see him in the starting line up against Leicester.

all you have to say is 3 starts in a week from someone who has been out for 5 months, it’s a joke, baffling decision from our medical team.

citymad said:
I think most of us was surprised he played for 70 mins in his come back game. I think that's pretty shocking from our medical team to be honest. He even waved to the bench to tell them he's time was up.
Click to expand...

I’m really starting to question our medical team. Players returning from injury need to be eased in. It’s the same with any sport, hell even with the normal gym goer, everyone knows when you’ve been out of the gym for a longer period of time, when you come back you ease yourself in.

Match Fitness needs to be built up slowly. I’m sure clubs around Europe are laughing at our medical team.

the decision to start a player in 3 games in one week who is just returning from a 5 month layoff is nothing short of a comedy.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top