Is the club going to put in an official complaint about the officiating on Saturday?

One bad decision I can take but three in one game is over the top. The club have to ask questions.

1,No hand ball because the defender had his hands close to his body! So now according to that rule you can defend with you elbows tucked in & your hands spread facing the ball.

2, No Penalty on Phil Foden because the foul wasn't classed as a yellow card! I Didn't realise the challenge had to warrant a yellow card to get the penalty, nether the less the defender is reckless with studs showing. If that challenge happens anywhere else on the pitch it's a foul.

3, The VAR offside decision for their second goal is very suspicious! To the naked eye the Newcastle player looks offside and when the automated still is shown to the fans you can clearly see that the line has been altered. Why is Dias on the still frame shown to be jumping in the air when he didn't & when did the rule change so that a defender can be playing an attacker onside with his elbow?
It wasn't three, it was around ten
In addition to the three you've mentioned, there were numerous border line yellow card fouls committed by Newcastle and not only were no yellow cards shown for any, the bent bastard didn't even give a yellow for persistent fouling
 
Other managers after that ankle breaker in Foden would of come out full guns blazing with “that tackle could of ended fodens caree” then going on about seems players against us csn foul us 4/5 times without a booking where as we do 2 fouls we get booked!
The relative 'ease' with which we pick up a yellow card is stark compared to opposition getting one. We will pick up card for complaining about a poor decision whilst opposition choppers are jsut penalised with a free kick. Just ask Bernardo!
 
It wouldn’t make a difference.

I remember a few years ago pep complained about numerous red cards for opponents not given.
Our beloved BBC ran an article listing all the instances and basically said as only one led to a serious injury only that one should have been a red card.

The media fucking hate us and evidently so do the PL.
we will probably get a fine for complaining.
 
They should absolutely be doing it IMO - this wouldn't be dipperesque sour grapes (one thing that doesn't go their way in amongst a sea of favourable decisions), city were thoroughly shafted on Saturday and it needs highlighting and forced into the media. It won't change the result, but it might make the cheating twats be not so so brazen in future matches.
No.
 
Damned right we should call out the unfair and biased treatment which we get from PiGMOL officials, but that would only backfire on the club big style imo.

From the PL's numerous and deliberate attacks on the club, taking into account their funding of PiGMOL and its officials, allied to the sycophantic media, and the collective bias would result in an even more vindictive and orchestrated attack(s) on the club.
 
We should as it was so blatantly obvious that it needs bringing up, and this is after the Bournemouth goal and Villa goal v us, both of which should also have been fouls.
The ref is another Taylor, clearly Rag loving but claims to support someone else.
He reffed the Rags v Burnley. 9 fouls each in the game yet 5 Burnley bookings and 1 Rag in the 78th minute (token)
He also reffed the Rags v Spurs, Spurs 10 fouls and 5 cards and Rags 8 fouls and just 1 card in the 76th minute (token)
So v the Rags, he cannot get his cards out quick enough for the opposition yet v us, on top of the non penalty calls and laughable offside where Dias ended up in the air on their graphic, he let Newcastle foul at will without any caution )complete contrast to his performance for the Rags) yet had no issues booking us.
 
My personal view is that Simon Cliff should have been waiting outside Webb's office at 9am this morning with a team of lawyers. Because that performance by Barrott was clearly bent.

Here's another match he reffed, also involving Newcastle, that the opposition manager had something to say about - https://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/football/67739716
 
No. We all have a go at arsenal and liverpool fans when they behave in this way after a bad decision, so let's not lower ourselves to that level.

Yes the ref had a bad game, but it's time to move on. The far more worrying thing to me was how toothless we looked.
 
Regarding the referee's decisions definitely not. However we should challenge the non offside which led to their goal, that's a black or white decision and they fucked up, I want to know why.
 
The PL, FA or the media don’t give a rats arse about City so it would be a total waste of time
It would lay down a marker to referees which is why clubs like Arsenal, Liverpool, and United do it. We need to stop looking like a push over. We need to ask why Craig Pawson did not call the referee to the monitor. The same thing happened with the Rashford/Fernande incident at Old Trafford. We are not robust enough with our communications all round. On the train after the match I didnt hear from a single Newcastle fan who didn't think it was a penalty on Foden. A wild mistimed studs up lunge is always a foul on any part of the pitch. Why didn't the ref actually watch the video. The club should ask for Pawson (and Attwell for the swamp game) not to be involved in our matches. We need to be on the front foot. Being passive gets you nowhere.
 
Most of the replies show why we get treated the way we do. No push back, no complaints, just puff our chests out and mutter something along the lines of “we’re not scousers blah fucking blah”
Meanwhile we get fucked over continuously whilst the media remain eerily quiet and client journalists, pundits and refs rush to the cameras to explain all is above board and we have nothing to complain about, all decisions are subjective or some other bollocks.
Nobody wants to be a scouser or utd fan, in general they are the worst cunts in football, but they do defend their club when they get fucked over and it often works.
City fans, nah, nothing to see here, move along until the next week when we can do it all again.

Fucking right we should, as a club make a stand. Regardless of our success we’ve been a soft touch for too long.
 
It would lay down a marker to referees which is why clubs like Arsenal, Liverpool, and United do it. We need to stop looking like a push over. We need to ask why Craig Pawson did not call the referee to the monitor. The same thing happened with the Rashford/Fernande incident at Old Trafford. We are not robust enough with our communications all round. On the train after the match I didnt hear from a single Newcastle fan who didn't think it was a penalty on Foden. A wild mistimed studs up lunge is always a foul on any part of the pitch. Why didn't the ref actually watch the video. The club should ask for Pawson (and Attwell for the swamp game) not to be involved in our matches. We need to be on the front foot. Being passive gets you nowhere.

Yep we might be saying asking PGMOL but to get real attention you have to make it more public and moan in front of the camera live not in a press conference where we won’t get any sympathy unlike the certain clubs
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top