Isco (merged)

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dax777 said:
Mine was just an opinion. Yours however is just poor reasoning. Madrid doesn't play in the Prem so a player that might win us a league may not be enough to do the same for them. I mean it's not like we have Barcelona to contend with here.

2nd, Madrid is not City, a player that doesn't start for then can very well be a title winning catalyst for s team in another league.

So ease up Grinch!
Click to expand...

Higuain being a perfect example
 
Dax777 said:
And that team would improve our possession and probably win us the league. Those were my thoughts all along :)
Click to expand...


Then perhaps if you could articulate better, we would see it as "your opinion" rather than you coming over as it being fact, which we all know is bollocks

This is your post that I initially responded to. Doesn't look like an opinion to me.

If we get Isco, we will win the league. We probably will without him. But definitely with him.
 
Yeah, we're more than likely not bringing anyone in imo. We'd need to sell someone unless I'm mistaken and nobody looks to be going anywhere.
 
mosssideblue said:
Then perhaps if you could articulate better, we would see it as "your opinion" rather than you coming over as it being fact, which we all know is bollocks

This is your post that I initially responded to. Doesn't look like an opinion to me.

If we get Isco, we will win the league. We probably will without him. But definitely with him.
Click to expand...
Yes, that's my opinion. A belief in that which has yet to happen.

To that effect, no one we sign or don't sign will guarantee anything. Do you generally assume when folks say, 'if Aguero can stay healthy, we will win the league' that they are stating a fact? Or simply an opinion they hold - even if you do share that opinion?

In this context, (I.e football discussions) facts are things that have happened. Opinions are things that you believe but are yet to happen or are unprovable at the time of stating them. Whether I believe it with an air of certitude is irrelevant.

It is not hard to differentiate btw the 2. But as a matter of detail, the 'definitely will with him' modifies the previous sentence. I was simply expressing my level of confidence, I.e. we likely will win anyways, but he is a good insurance we will.

But regardless of how you choose to read it. It is still an opinion.

BTW: are you MaineRoadblue?
 
Dax777 said:
Yes, that's my opinion. A belief in that which has yet to happen.

To that effect, no one we sign or don't sign will guarantee anything. Do you generally assume when folks say, 'if Aguero can stay healthy, we will win the league' that they are stating a fact? Or simply an opinion they hold - even if you do share that opinion?

In this context, (I.e football discussions) facts are things that have happened. Opinions are things that you believe but are yet to happen or are unprovable at the time of stating them. Whether I believe it with an air of certitude is irrelevant.

It is not hard to differentiate btw the 2. But as a matter of detail, the 'definitely will with him' modifies the previous sentence. I was simply expressing my level of confidence, I.e. we likely will win anyways, but he is a good insurance we will.

But regardless of how you choose to read it. It is still an opinion.

BTW: are you MaineRoadblue?
Click to expand...

Why do you ask?
 
Real know they sent getting a transfer ban in the summer now, which would make things easier.


But you still can't get past the fact we have a full squad and no one leaving. Makes the move impossible.
 
domalino said:
Real know they sent getting a transfer ban in the summer now, which would make things easier.


But you still can't get past the fact we have a full squad and no one leaving. Makes the move impossible.
Click to expand...

Forgive me if i'm wrong but hypothetically, couldn't he take Nasri or KDB's Prem spot? I dpubt it will happen, but 1 is getting over his muscles detaching from his leg and the other has ligament damage to both ankle and knee. Not that I think it will happen, but it wouldn't exactly be illogical for the club to prefer them to have a summer of getting up to match fitness rather than hoping they'd be up to speed for the last 5/6 tough games we have.
 
Ajm1985 said:
Forgive me if i'm wrong but hypothetically, couldn't he take Nasri or KDB's Prem spot? I dpubt it will happen, but 1 is getting over his muscles detaching from his leg and the other has ligament damage to both ankle and knee. Not that I think it will happen, but it wouldn't exactly be illogical for the club to prefer them to have a summer of getting up to match fitness rather than hoping they'd be up to speed for the last 5/6 tough games we have.
Click to expand...

It would be absolutely ludicrous to do that and would probably piss off everyone else in the first team.

We can't just become a team that writes everyone out of the squad whenever they get an injury for more than a month.

It would be illogical. It would be completely illogical.
 
domalino said:
Real know they sent getting a transfer ban in the summer now, which would make things easier.


But you still can't get past the fact we have a full squad and no one leaving. Makes the move impossible.
Click to expand...
Not for domestic games.......he's cup tied in Europe anyway........ But if the price is right!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top