It's Quiet 17 - Glory Thread

samuelyeboah said:
I don't know what the point of this debate is. The dude got this one very wrong, he wasn't mincing about and definitely said very clearly that Neymar is coming, and he isn't. Who knows what happened behind the scenes but for sure he was wrong and this will harm his credibility. I am not gonna start calling him a liar or hurl abuse at them, I still think they probably do know a thing or two inside the club, they got quite a few things right including exact days of announcement etc

My guess is whoever gave them the info didn't vet it properly, maybe lied to them, there was an inkling of conversation and they took it to mean something else. That's it
Click to expand...
Could also have been set up by their source with a false rumour
 
bluenova said:
Not sure what a wido is, but football is pretty clearly based around seasons, and the Torres and Alvarez transfers were both in January, which was last season.

Torres obviously played half a season in Barcelona, while the Alvarez deal was 5.5 years, and reported at the time as City buying him then loaning him back to River Plate.
Click to expand...

Maybe on transfermarket. In reality, last season began witht he closing of last summer's transfer window. This season begins with the clisong of this one. January rolls into that, it can't go backwards.

Torres was at City last season, he won't be this season, Alvarez wasn't last season will be this season. The impact on both transfers, financial and footballing, is within this one.
 
Coatigan said:
Maybe on transfermarket. In reality, last season began witht he closing of last summer's transfer window. This season begins with the clisong of this one. January rolls into that, it can't go backwards.

Torres was at City last season, he won't be this season, Alvarez wasn't last season will be this season. The impact on both transfers, financial and footballing, is within this one.
Click to expand...
Didn't last season's games begin before the summer transfer window shut? What was Torres doing in Barcelona if he wasn't footballing? And don't City's financial accounts run till the end of June, rather than up to the start of the new season? Questions need answers.

On the other hand - no they don't. I was just explaining to someone why whoever compiled the list hadn't included Torres and Alvarez. If you produce a different list with them on, I won't complain :)
 
Cricket Blue said:
Let's face it noone knows f all.
Things things are always guess work at best.
Click to expand...
Quite right..most of the banter is fun..some strange opinions but such is life...will be very surprised if we do not get a LB though..would be the strangest decision as a fan.
 
DanJ210 said:
you can see on his profile he was last seen 9 minutes ago so he's here just not speaking
Click to expand...

He‘s not a prolific poster…. Just shares what he hears from time to time. He’s a positive contributor to this site - but you wouldn’t think so given the childish abuse a few have subjected him to in recent days…. Who wanted Neymar anyway?
 
Alan Harper's Tash said:
Nobody should be 0 or 100% about any information on this forum. Deals aren’t done until they are 100% done. Therefore anybody can be made right or wrong if the transfer saga fluctuates.

Remember the Delph signing? One day an ITK was supreme, then a **** etc.

Just enjoy the ride.
Click to expand...
I'm not sure even Delph knew how that one would pan out. He did that video to the Villa fans saying was definitely staying finishing with a cheeky wink to camera and a week later pitches up at The Etihad.

Obviously that only serves to reinforce your point.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top