It's Quiet - a new dawn

Status
Not open for further replies.
Honestly don't get what people see in Rose. I've never seen him have an exceptional game, just a few decent ones. Walker's another one who's pace makes him look more impressive than he is, in my opinion. Maybe I've just missed their standout performances.

I'd be underwhelmed to say the least if we went into next season with those two as our fullbacks.
 
Rose is decent player but i cant stand him...huge cheat..

I thought I wouldn't take to bellamy when he arrived but I did so maybe there is a chance for Rose as well if we were to get him....

Rather have someone else though

Same goes for Bellerin - he just seems to be a bit of a sneaky bastard...someone that would shaft over anyone/any club the moment he gets a chance......again decent player and i know we cant have a team full of nice guys but its hard to form a link to these types of players as a fan....easy when its someone like Zabba, Vinnie, etc but these two mentioned above are the exact opposite
 
Rose & Walker are exactly what City need, best right & left back in Prem, put that together with Loris it's what we are crying out for.

To say Rose is overrated is wrong, stop both Walker & Rose & Spurs loose games simple.

Now Deli Ali is certainly overrated
 
deano ou812 said:
Only if the money is right,which will be far to much ..
Click to expand...
Not sure why fans go on about what he or him will cost, there all over priced inc City players.

Not arsed one bit if Rose costs £35 or £50 million but I would throw everything at him he is top draw Premier & International proven
 
harvo the blue said:
Rose & Walker are exactly what City need, best right & left back in Prem, put that together with Loris it's what we are crying out for.

To say Rose is overrated is wrong, stop both Walker & Rose & Spurs loose games simple.

Now Deli Ali is certainly overrated
Click to expand...
We wont be buying from Tottenham, they wouldnt sell to us, and I'm fairly certain none of their players would push to leave. The only way would be to offer silly money and why would we do that when players as good or better from abroad are much easier to get.
 
harvo the blue said:
Rose & Walker are exactly what City need, best right & left back in Prem, put that together with Loris it's what we are crying out for.

To say Rose is overrated is wrong, stop both Walker & Rose & Spurs loose games simple.

Now Deli Ali is certainly overrated
Click to expand...

Why shell out £75mil+ on them though? Surely our scouts can find some good players for much cheaper and younger too
 
harvo the blue said:
Not sure why fans go on about what he or him will cost, there all over priced inc City players.

Not arsed one bit if Rose costs £35 or £50 million but I would throw everything at him he is top draw Premier & International proven
Click to expand...
International proven? What's he achieved at international level? If tonight proved anything, it's that England are a million miles off what our club is trying to achieve.

The real question is would you want him if he wasn't English. The answer is almost certainly no. Having said that, I was wanting us to sign Rose when he was 22 or 23.
 
blueparrot said:
We wont be buying from Tottenham, they wouldnt sell to us, and I'm fairly certain none of their players would push to leave. The only way would be to offer silly money and why would we do that when players as good or better from abroad are much easier to get.
Click to expand...
Levy will sell, there is a price for all his players. They will try & hang onto Ali & move on players like Rose if price is right. Stones is worth it & Rose is to IMO.

Spurs would take £50m in one lump sum they have a new stadium to pay for
 
I'm With Stupid said:
International proven? What's he achieved at international level? If tonight proved anything, it's that England are a million miles off what our club is trying to achieve.

The real question is would you want him if he wasn't English. The answer is almost certainly no. Having said that, I was wanting us to sign Rose when he was 22 or 23.
Click to expand...
You answered your own question

England have & will underachiever but that don't mean Rose isn't good enough, Like I said before there isn't a better left back in the Prem.

Now if you want a better player who has won World or Euros or Chumps league then please name 1???

Realistically we ain't getting Bayern, Barca or Madrids left back so over & out for me.

It's Rose or Mendy from Monaco & nobody else.
 
harvo the blue said:
You answered your own question

England have & will underachiever but that don't mean Rose isn't good enough, Like I said before there isn't a better left back in the Prem.

Now if you want a better player who has won World or Euros or Chumps league then please name 1???

Realistically we ain't getting Bayern, Barca or Madrids left back so over & out for me.

It's Rose or Mendy from Monaco & nobody else.
Click to expand...

Think about how ludicrous that is though, £50m for Danny fucking Rose. There are so many options out there, who even knew about Mendy last year? Barely anyone. We should have signed Alex Sandro, ~£22mil for him is a steal. Grimaldo for £1.5mil. Guerriero for £9.5mil.
 
LB options we've been linked to: Grimaldo, Gaya, Bernat, T. Hernandez, Mendy, Ghoulam, Stafylidis, Kolasinac, Wendell
RB options: Henrichs, R. Pereira, Hysaj, Bellerin, Fabinho, Sidibe, Semedo

Sooooo many options
 
Wouldn't be surprised if we were interested in Rose, what with Guardiola's comments a while back moaning about the price of English players.

Not a chance we should pay the asking price for him though. Personally i hope we forget about targeting English players and focus on producing our own. Some extremely talented kids in our youth teams.
 
harvo the blue said:
Rose & Walker are exactly what City need, best right & left back in Prem, put that together with Loris it's what we are crying out for.

To say Rose is overrated is wrong, stop both Walker & Rose & Spurs loose games simple.

Now Deli Ali is certainly overrated
Click to expand...
The problem with fullback suggestions is that ours were so weak this season that any decent player would be an upgrade. Yea that includes Rose and Walker. And while they might be considered 2 of the better fullbacks in the league, this doesn't necessarily make them the best fit.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top