It's Quiet thread 14 - 'do one' edition

Status
Not open for further replies.
The way I see it is we now have 3 outcomes.

Barca negotiate a fee for Messi with us and sell him for circa £100mil. This is what is the easiest and best for all parties and seemingly what Messi is trying to get them to do.

If they continue to refuse then that leaves us with 2 other options.

Messi takes them to court over his contract about this free clause and Barca run the risk of losing him for nothing. Barti's quotes from last year do him no favours.
Or
The Webster ruling is invoked and FIFA settle the price. Again Barca run the risk of losing a decent amount of money.

The one guarantee is Messi has played his last game for Barca
Very small possibility that there's ructions politically at barca enabling a new regime. That was Sky and mainstream media's initial angle on this. A messi plot to infuence the Barca regime. I think we can discount that.

I agree with your conclusions.

I think we all independently came to the same place which is quite good although we all share the same overall bias. I wonder what observers like Balague and Sid Lowe think. Their opinion will be interesting.
 
Surely city's legal team have gone over and over his contract with a fine tooth Combe and if they had any doubts about the legality of the finer points they wouldn't of advised H.R.H and khaldoon to press the button and put the wheels in motion to make him ours
As always we are acting with professionalism and integrity as an organisation till the NUCLEAR BUTTON is pressed
We are playing a blinder in my eyes
 
But he is under contract so even that doesnt mean they will have to sell - of course it would be very difficult fo them to keep him and not play him or play him knowing his mindset (though over time with being at the club, around friends and the fans that could change his mind also)

It also means we will have to pay for him doesnt it? ((f Barca are willing to negotiate)
If it turns out that it’s Barca in the right, I don’t see it getting done this season.
Barca haven’t changed their stance that it’s €700m or it doesn’t get done, even if they were to negotiate I still see the fee being €200m-€300m.
Wouldn’t have thought it’d be financially viable.
Also would Messi want us paying a fee when in his eyes he’s a free to leave player? Could be a point of principle.
The Webster ruling is the other option, but I’ve seen conflicting reports/posts on that option.
This will probably end up in the courts, we’ve basically gone round in circles over the last few days.
Just my opinion on the way it’s looking and progressing, hopefully I’m wrong but we seem to be at a stalemate at the minute.
 
I'd be interested in a lawyer's take on this, if his legal team have advised him not to fulfil any club obligations as that could be seen as honouring a contract he doesn't believe is valid, trying to get Barca to honour the agreement? Or if its just posturing in the hope that Barca agree to the transfer...

Either way, he's doing his bit to try and make the move happen which looks very positive for us. Fingers crossed.

Without actually seeing his contract I’m not sure any lawyer would have anything relevant to say.

Doesn’t seem to have stopped La Liga, however.
 
If it turns out that it’s Barca in the right, I don’t see it getting done this season.
Barca haven’t changed their stance that it’s €700m or it doesn’t get done, even if they were to negotiate I still see the fee being €200m-€300m.
Wouldn’t have thought it’d be financially viable.
Also would Messi want us paying a fee when in his eyes he’s a free to leave player? Could be a point of principle.
The Webster ruling is the other option, but I’ve seen conflicting reports/posts on that option.
This will probably end up in the courts, we’ve basically gone round in circles over the last few days.
Just my opinion on the way it’s looking and progressing, hopefully I’m wrong but we seem to be at a stalemate at the minute.

Why would the fee be 200 million ?
 
If it turns out that it’s Barca in the right, I don’t see it getting done this season.
Barca haven’t changed their stance that it’s €700m or it doesn’t get done, even if they were to negotiate I still see the fee being €200m-€300m.
Wouldn’t have thought it’d be financially viable.
Also would Messi want us paying a fee when in his eyes he’s a free to leave player? Could be a point of principle.
The Webster ruling is the other option, but I’ve seen conflicting reports/posts on that option.
This will probably end up in the courts, we’ve basically gone round in circles over the last few days.
Just my opinion on the way it’s looking and progressing, hopefully I’m wrong but we seem to be at a stalemate at the minute.


fuck me, back again with absolute drivel.
 
If it turns out that it’s Barca in the right, I don’t see it getting done this season.
Barca haven’t changed their stance that it’s €700m or it doesn’t get done, even if they were to negotiate I still see the fee being €200m-€300m.
Wouldn’t have thought it’d be financially viable.
Also would Messi want us paying a fee when in his eyes he’s a free to leave player? Could be a point of principle.
The Webster ruling is the other option, but I’ve seen conflicting reports/posts on that option.
This will probably end up in the courts, we’ve basically gone round in circles over the last few days.
Just my opinion on the way it’s looking and progressing, hopefully I’m wrong but we seem to be at a stalemate at the minute.
They would have to be beyond stupid to demand that though. Ronaldo went for 100 million euros at the same age, with more than one year left on his contract.
 
Why would the fee be 200 million ?
Because at the minute Barca are saying €700m or it doesn’t happen, just don’t see it getting done for €100m if Barca still believe he his under contract.
It’s just down to who’s right and who’s wrong and that’s where the stalemate seems to be.
 
Without actually seeing his contract I’m not sure any lawyer would have anything relevant to say.

Doesn’t seem to have stopped La Liga, however.

I may be wrong(?) but I have it in my head that European football associations require a copy of all player / club contracts so that they can establish their validity / ensure 3rd Party ownership isn't an issue etc. as part of the registration process to play in their leagues.
Can anyone actually clued up on this topic confirm one way or the other please?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.