Was he really though? Kompany was criticised for not being pragmatic enough to change his progress style to suit a promoted team
Last season in the Championship they were very much defense first.
Under Kompany, Burnley played a more expansive game like he would be doing at our place and he was dropped after 6 months or so.
He will likely have improved since then no doubt, but going from an organised defensive unit in the second division to an all out attack open expansive game at City where every goal conceded could be the difference between winning the league or CL is a huge step up.