Lescott?

[Le Havre Oswald]

Nasty's a liability. Giving that corner away the other day and nearly gave a goal away yesterday. He's young but has too many mistakes in him.

At least he is not carcrashSavic

Savic got crucified and he's anly about 21-22, i've seen Nasty make a good few mistakes so far and i ain't gonna go as far and say he's shite but he has cost us a bit this season.

No

 

[Skip Donoghue]

Nasty's a liability. Giving that corner away the other day and nearly gave a goal away yesterday. He's young but has too many mistakes in him.

At least he is not carcrashSavic

Savic and Nastasic are worlds apart, Nastasic may have made a couple of errors but he ain't made as many as Kompany this season so by your logic Kompany has been a liability also..... he is young but has bags of potential, he looks like he belongs at this level and will only get better he looks more accomplished in half a dozen games than Savic did in all his time with us....Savic was found wanting in all departments and will never be a top player, Nastasic on the other hand will

 

[ell]

i think he'll leave at the end of the season

Where to?

I would be amazed if he did

 

[Super David Silva 21]

Nasty's a liability. Giving that corner away the other day and nearly gave a goal away yesterday. He's young but has too many mistakes in him.

At least he is not carcrashSavic

Savic and Nastasic are worlds apart, Nastasic may have made a couple of errors but he ain't made as many as Kompany this season so by your logic Kompany has been a liability also..... he is young but has bags of potential, he looks like he belongs at this level and will only get better he looks more accomplished in half a dozen games than Savic did in all his time with us....Savic was found wanting in all departments and will never be a top player, Nastasic on the other hand will

Kompany has cost us this season to, ducking his head for Reals 3rd goal at the Bernabeu being a major one.

 

[Deleted member 52846]

Nasty's a liability. Giving that corner away the other day and nearly gave a goal away yesterday. He's young but has too many mistakes in him.

A liability, he is not. Anyone can miskick a ball, most players do it in every game. It's not the giving away of the corner why they scored from the corner.

 

[Skip Donoghue]

At least he is not carcrashSavic

Savic and Nastasic are worlds apart, Nastasic may have made a couple of errors but he ain't made as many as Kompany this season so by your logic Kompany has been a liability also..... he is young but has bags of potential, he looks like he belongs at this level and will only get better he looks more accomplished in half a dozen games than Savic did in all his time with us....Savic was found wanting in all departments and will never be a top player, Nastasic on the other hand will

Kompany has cost us this season to, ducking his head for Reals 3rd goal at the Bernabeu being a major one.

you can add to that his fuck up at WBA for, Milners sending off also, getting robbed yesterday by Ade and spurs nearly scoring, but he is still the best centre half in the league and shit happens......but by your logic he is a liability as you have stated that Nastasic is and he hasn't made half the errors this season that Kompany has

 

[reedy]

Nasty's a liability. Giving that corner away the other day and nearly gave a goal away yesterday. He's young but has too many mistakes in him.

At least he is not carcrashSavic

Savic got crucified and he's anly about 21-22, i've seen Nasty make a good few mistakes so far and i ain't gonna go as far and say he's shite but he has cost us a bit this season.

i'll take Nasty over savic every day

 

[Marvin]

City's defenders play one on one for a lot of the time ie. they are not protected by a back 4 and packed midfield. So many times we have pushed our full backs way upfield and Barry doens't provide the cover that De Jong did

Therefore City's defensive record is very very good. Utd play a similar attacking style but contrast their goals against. Largely due to Ferdinand. Kompany has made mistakes but he has still been outstanding

 

[St Ives blue]

Looks accomplished to me even at the age of 19.
Sure he's made a few minor errors this season, but who hasn't?
Maybe we should get rid of Yaya, he's given the ball away a few times over the last few weeks!

 

[kunaguero10]

i think he'll leave at the end of the season

Where to?

I would be amazed if he did

i don't know, another prem team cos mancini seems to have made up his mind and prefers nasty over lescott, and lescott is too good to sit on the bench.

if lescott wants regular football, we may move him on while he still has some resell value imo