The first surprise last night was when I saw that all the tickets had in fact sold and that the ground was not full of scousers who had bought four tickets each. Then they came out of the tunnel and the YNWA on the back of their shirts reminded me that my all consuming desire for a City win had only a little to do with the PL table but was only more intense than my desire every season - and it was shared by all those packed into the stadium, who never wavered in their determination to will the lads to victory. Wow! What a performance! What a team performance! Liverpool showed what a good team they are: City showed what a great side we are. Our midfield is just dreamlike in its quality, but how hard they work! Ferna - what can we say? David - we've said it all before many times! Bernardo - brilliant, and has he ever worked harder or run further? And up front? Leroy, a thorn in the side of Liverpool all night and a magnificent finish for the goal. Raheem always direct, used his pace well and played a decisive part in the build up to the winner. And Sergio showing just how truly great he is with an unbelievable finish for his goal. And what a surprise that he ignored VVD and honed in on Lovren like heat seeking missile - far too cunning for a world class striker! But for me the real heroes were the lads at the back. Pep was accused of another strange "left field" selection but with Walker struggling for form he actually played the only available defenders he had, and how they responded. Danilo had a fine game and Laporte was excellent (did Salah have a meaningful touch all night?). Stones will always be remembered for one clearance which seemed to defy the laws of physics, but he was admirable all night and Vinnie was a model of calm, defensive composure all night and he did not, categorically and definitely not, commit a red card offence. For a back four which has never played together it was superb, especially with Ederson giving an exemplary display as "the spare man at the back". And yet I don't think we were ever at our best or hit top form. It was our effort, our team spirit, the collective determination to do nothing but win which saw us over the line. And that goes for the crowd as well; the vocal support never wavered. Much is made this morning that no one has heard noise like that at the Etihad before - no one has actually heard noise like that anywhere! City and the crowd were simply tougher, harder psychologically than Liverpool and the victory was well deserved.