Mata vs Silva (Who would you pick)

[thenabster]

These are probably the best two Spaniard in the league right now (Honorable mention to Carzorla and Michu)

Both play similar positions and are key players for their teams. Silva has amazing footwork while Mata is a better goal scorer.

So trying to be as unbiased as possible, who would you rather have in your lineup ?

 

[stony]

Silva all day every day.

 

[Sam.]

Silva, by a country mile anall.

 

[Paul11/12]

These are probably the best two Spaniard in the league right now (Honorable mention to Carzorla and Michu)

Both play similar positions and are key players for their teams. Silva has amazing footwork while Mata is a better goal scorer.

So trying to be as unbiased as possible, who would you rather have in your lineup ?

If Silva had a finishers touch he'd be very close to Messi, but as it is he's the best Spaniard in the English game followed by Carzola IMO, I thought he was immense at our place!

 

[TCIB]

100% looking without blue specs i would have Silva no doubt.

Mata is good but not close to Dave imo.

 

[Why Always Ste]

Silva. As an all round footballer he is more creative and involved with play.

Needs to work on his finishing though.

 

[jollylescott]

David is in the first 11 for possibly the best national team we have ever seen. Mata can't get a look in.

I think we should trust the judgement of Del Bosque. Simple as that.

 

[Anonymous]

my mates who support neither all say silva.

including the rags.

 

[c4lv3rt]

No brainer - merlin

 

[daxman]

6 and half a dozen. You couldn't go wrong with either. They both have their strenghts. Silva is more pleasing to watch. But I doubt that makes him necessarily better. Mata has his qualities too. So does Carzolla.

All 3 are a treat. And they should all have been City players :(