Match Thread | FC Copenhagen vs Man City (11/10/22)

[stan bowles]

The rags do it at the swamp and have done for years

While the game is in motion ?

 

[DTKOAG]

Glad we’re getting fucked over in a group game rather than in the knockout stage

 

[Mariosfireworks]

It checks for handballs in the build up to goals. In the PL, that goal would have stood, but not in the CL.

Clear and obvious is to do with subjective foul decisions.

See I don't even know the rules of football anymore, it's become a fucking joke

 

[union city blue]

I thought it had to be deliberate if it’s in the build up?

You can only disallow for any handball if it’s the person putting the ball in the net.

Yep. This is the explanation of the handball law given on the BBC’s website this morning when discussing some of this weekend’s decisions:

For accidental handball in the build-up to a goal:

• If one player accidentally handles the ball and a team-mate scores, the goal is given;
• However, if a player accidentally handles the ball themselves and goes on to score, the goal will not stand.

 

[Matt the Giant]

A ridiculous VAR decision.

 

[Bluearmy]

The rule is different from the PL who amended it, can’t see how you can have different rules in association football

The rule is applied differently if you’re an attacker or a defender isnt it

 

[Deleted member 77198]

I thiught it was only the guy who scores then it has to be ruled out?

Or if the handball sets up a goal scoring action, which it didn’t. Ref got it wrong.

 

[Champions again in 2012]

That var intervention is fucking outrageous- i thought one a few years ago against spurs when it brushed Laporte arm from a corner was bad but I thought it now came down to the player scoring the goal being the one to handle. The ball was subsequently played by Mahrez to Alvarez and then on to Rodri.

if a defender handles it like that in the box it’s never a penalty so we have to standards of handball one by the attacking team and one by the defenders

 

[grandsolo]

In the PL, yes, not in the CL.

So it’s not just us, the commentators have no clue of the rule either. They said it can’t be handball

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

Fuck VAR. We'll have to win the game where they cannot possibly deny us, and we will. Have faith...

 

[Bluearmy]

Yep. This is the explanation of the handball law given on the BBC’s website this morning when discussing some of this weekend’s decisions:

For accidental handball in the build-up to a goal:

• If one player accidentally handles the ball and a team-mate scores, the goal is given;
• However, if a player accidentally handles the ball themselves and goes on to score, the goal will not stand.

Is it different in Europe

 

[Beanhead]

No, it isn’t. The rule says if a player intentionally handballs in the build up (which Mahrez didn’t) or if the scoring player handballs (intentional or not), which Rodri didn’t.

They are just making it up as they go now.

No mate.. the rule changed recently (before last season I believe?!?).
Got rid of the ‘intentional’ part and changed it to any handball contact in the build up to a goal would be chalked off.

 

[deano ou812]

Ederson "Manchester United goalkeeper"?

Quality commentating from BT Sport

They wish ..

 

[Deleted member 77198]

A ridiculous VAR decision.

It was the ref, not VAR.

 

[Alan Harper's Tash]

So it’s not just us, the commentators have no clue of the rule either. They said it can’t be handball

Does that surprise you?

 

[IcriedwhenTueartleft]

Ederson...fucks up first touch and almost scores an OG, then pings another pass straight to Copenhagen player and they nearly score....waken up laddie

 

[MCFC1993]

I thought the goal was fine due to the rule change in the Premier League.

Had no idea they were still using that shit rule in the Champions League.

 

[yankblue]

Gundogan has sexy hair

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Is it different in Europe

Or is it just different when we score?

 

[super_city_si]

The handball rule should be universal for Europe and domestic leagues,not one rule there and one here and so on ..

How can there be different rules? I thought it was all under UEFA/FIFA? Stupid.