I guess, much like the klopp v pep argument, we'll never be able to work out the better player
Player A -
510 games, 120 goals, 92 assists, 0 premier leagues, 255 wins, 119 losses, PFA players player of the year - 1, Premier league player of the year - 0, Hilarious Errors leading to losing the premier league title - 1
Player B -
244 games, 65 goals, 103 assists, 5 premier leagues, 171 wins, 32 losses, PFA players player of the year - 2, Premier league player of the year - 2, Beautifully weighted curling passes to assist on the winning goal to win the premier league title - 1.