I'd always go with the University Challenge version of from -Never said he wasn't from Manchester, I said "from" as in a resident.
I lived 10 years in the channel Islands and when their was "from" jersey, but I was still a Mancunian
Neville is neither from Manchester or a Mancunian, where as Noel is
"Hi, I'm madloaf, i'm from manchester and i'm studying media studies and the decline of sports journalism"
even if i was studying this and living somewhere else.
Still, you're right about neville - he's a **** from cuntsville.