Mulling over possible line-ups brings home the slight problem we have this year with balance, I think.
For me, our ‘best’ side would probably be:
—————Ederson——-
—-Akanji—Dias—Ake—-
——-Stones—Rodri—
Bernardo-KDB-Foden-Grealish
————Haaland———-
Big game, everyone fit, that’s what I’d hope to see. Not quite the same as last year, but a decent balance between controlling players who rarely lose the ball (Stones, Rodri, Bernardo and Grealish) and the more high risk, high reward players (KDB, Foden, Haaland).
Take Grealish out of that and replace him with any of Doku, Alvarez, Nunes, even Bobb, and it feels like the balance tips too far towards those riskier players who want to make things happen, but are susceptible to losing the ball and inviting counters.
Alternatively, you bring Kovacic in and play him alongside Rodri. That gives us a more solid look, but then we end up with six more defensive players, which can make us look much less threatening going forward (and goes against Pep’s preferred 5/5 split). Meaning we end up committing one of (or both) the fullbacks higher up, which (in Walker’s case particularly) is largely a waste of time in an attacking sense, and leaves big gaps down the sides of the centre halves.
Feels like the squad does need a tweak in the summer - a top class Gundogan replacement who can control games (and be creative and score goals, ideally!) and maybe a proper attacking full back that Pep fully trusts.
None of which has much to do with the weekend’s game, which I reckon we’ll win comfortably.