Nicolas Otamendi

[Thorin Oakenshield]

So who to replace him?

 

[Damien10]

I hope he stays, the guy is a warrior.

 

[Txiki Txiki Bang Bang]

I hope he stays, the guy is a warrior.

Nope, we need to improve. He is in his 30's and has never really been a good CB. We can't let sentiment cloud our judgement. Cash in asap and go for a 20-24 year old Quality CB.

 

[p.taker]

Nope, we need to improve. He is in his 30's and has never really been a good CB. We can't let sentiment cloud our judgement. Cash in asap and go for a 20-24 year old Quality CB.

Never been that good? Oh dear.

 

[worsleyweb]

Nope, we need to improve. He is in his 30's and has never really been a good CB. We can't let sentiment cloud our judgement. Cash in asap and go for a 20-24 year old Quality CB.

Nonsene - been fantastic for us - a great player and not a minutes trouble - all be good our Argentines. Top lads.

 

[merz]

Nope, we need to improve. He is in his 30's and has never really been a good CB. We can't let sentiment cloud our judgement. Cash in asap and go for a 20-24 year old Quality CB.

had his hiccups but overall he was very good.

 

[KCblue]

Nope, we need to improve. He is in his 30's and has never really been a good CB. We can't let sentiment cloud our judgement. Cash in asap and go for a 20-24 year old Quality CB.

 

[p.taker]

^
Last season for anyone that can't put it together lol

 

[mosssideblue]

Nope, we need to improve. He is in his 30's and has never really been a good CB. We can't let sentiment cloud our judgement. Cash in asap and go for a 20-24 year old Quality CB.

Absolute bollocks

 

[I'm With Stupid]

I'd never choose to get rid of him, but if he wants to go somewhere to start every week, then he's earned the right. I'm definitely nervous about losing both him and Kompany though.

 

[nmc]

Never been that good? Oh dear.

I know our best defender last season.

 

[Dobsy]

Atletico makes sense for him and for city. Took time to settle into English football in his first season and became immense for us in the Centurions year. All the best to him.

 

[mosssideblue]

I'd never choose to get rid of him, but if he wants to go somewhere to start every week, then he's earned the right. I'm definitely nervous about losing both him and Kompany though.

All depends who comes in

 

[Dax777]

All depends who comes in

De Ligt that fire

 

[mosssideblue]

De Ligt that fire

Id prefer Phil the face if we could prize him off Olly

 

[Cellarite]

Id prefer Phil the face if we could prize him off Olly

Smalling as well if Vinny goes and I feel we’d be set.

 

[kaz7]

Nope, we need to improve. He is in his 30's and has never really been a good CB. We can't let sentiment cloud our judgement. Cash in asap and go for a 20-24 year old Quality CB.

Bollocks,he has been great for us

 

[Txiki Txiki Bang Bang]

Look guys, I know Otamendi always puts in 100% but the thing is he just isn't that good as a CB, he spends more time on his back than he does on his fit. I am sure he's good for the team's spirit but I've never really rated him, that's just my opinion anyway.

 

[City_Sean]

Look guys, I know Otamendi always puts in 100% but the thing is he just isn't that good as a CB, he spends more time on his back than he does on his fit. I am sure he's good for the team's spirit but I've never really rated him, that's just my opinion anyway.

What a load of bollocks this is.

 

[Larry Stranger]

The main thing with Otamendi is that although he's been good he has reached his ceiling. He'd done everything Pep has wanted him to do, but he's not going to gain anymore pace. He'll only get slower and it won't help when we get counter attacked on. His distribution isn't going to be any better also. Against Leicester Vinnie was pinging balls out to Bernardo on the wing. This is what is needed from our CB's when teams sit back. Might as well get one in now since Vinny will be going sometime soon as well.