You seem to be more observant than the people running city. If Joe public could see that last season we were an accident waiting to happen why didn't you bypass the forum and send your observation direct to Trixi bolloks at headquarters.
We all did.
Loads of people throughout our support said that they were expecting a drop-off last season after the exploits of the treble.
Then when Rodri was out of the team (three games at Wolves, Arsenal and Newcastle for his red card against Forest, and Villa for his accumulation of bookings)
we lost every single game.
De Bruyne got injured in the first game of last season and we didn’t see him until January. This time last year we had just 35 points at Christmas, just 8 more than we have at Christmas this season despite us winning just 1 in 12.
Every man and his dog knew and pointed out that we needed to bolster the midfield. Yet we didn’t. So this was inevitable. Even if the rest of the team were playing well, our midfield hasn’t had enough strength in depth of quality for a few years, so having no Rodri all season and De Bruyne struggling with injuries is our best two players not in our engine room running the show.
In 2018-19 we lost Fernandinho for the most part of the run-in and we didn’t notice, in 2020-21 we lost De Bruyne for most of the Winter and we didn’t notice… such was our strength in depth of quality.
At one point we had a midfield of: Fernandinho in his 30s was as good as any 27 year old in his prime in his position in world football, David Silva in his 30s was still almost good as any attacking midfielder in world football, De Bruyne was the best midfielder in the world, Bernardo Silva was the hardest working player covering more ground than anyone anywhere, Gündoğan was arguably better than all midfielders outside City in the PL yet he was our third best attacking midfielder, Rodri at 24 was an up-and-coming player.
Compare that to our midfield depth in the 2022-23 and 2023-24: okay, yeah De Bruyne, Rodri and Gündoğan all at their best… then an up-and-coming Foden who’d never really played in midfield since his youth team days and Kalvin Phillips, then last season Kovačić and Nunes.
In 2022-23 Rodri played 56 games, De Bruyne played 49 games and Gündoğan played 51 games… and that’s why we won’t be treble because they all played all the games we needed them to and we didn’t have to rely on our lack of depth there. If we had had to, we wouldn’t have won the treble.
Then, as I said, we struggled up to Christmas last season without De Bruyne and when Rodri was out of the team. If we’d had to rely on our poor depth in midfield in April last season, say, if Rodri had got another three game ban and/or De Bruyne had got injured again, we wouldn’t have won the title.
It’s hardly revelatory what I pointed out.