Aussie!
Well-Known Member
whens swp back?
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Our most indispensable player?
- Thread starter Kenney_The_Blue
- Start date
SWP?
Honestly??
I'm not saying he's a bad player or anything, or indeed we play better without him but, just look at our previous four games:
Sunderland (4-3) W
Stoke City (2-0) W
Wolves (3-0) W
Middlesbrough (1-0) W
Shay Given hands down.
Honestly??
I'm not saying he's a bad player or anything, or indeed we play better without him but, just look at our previous four games:
Sunderland (4-3) W
Stoke City (2-0) W
Wolves (3-0) W
Middlesbrough (1-0) W
Shay Given hands down.
GoForGlory
Well-Known Member
Definitely Given for me, but Tevez is amazing at the moment and a guiding light for the entire team. But I'm unsure of how Taylor would perform at the moment, the little we've seen wasn't very impressive (albeit it isn't fair to judge him on that, he is an accomplished keeper). Without Hart though the answer just has to be Given, without him we'd probably be mid table with no chances of CL footie next year.
BTW I love SWP and he can be fantastic when he's at his best but there's definitely cover for him at the moment.
BTW I love SWP and he can be fantastic when he's at his best but there's definitely cover for him at the moment.
lionheart
Well-Known Member
Marks out of 10 for indispensability;
Given 9
Tevez 6
Bellamy 6
De Jong 5
SWP 5
Robinho -2
Whoops!
Given 9
Tevez 6
Bellamy 6
De Jong 5
SWP 5
Robinho -2
Whoops!
Wheelsy
Well-Known Member
This man speaks sense.buckshot said:For me it's Given with Tevez a close 2nd. I love the way Tevez pressures opposing keepers when they are fielding back passes, they never have a chance to do anything even halfway creative.
Petr Čech
Well-Known Member
For me, it's gotta be Tevez. He is in red hot form and the biggest threat up front.
spacecadet
Well-Known Member
Bellamy
Lemmy
Well-Known Member
no contest. it has to be Garrido
M
M
manchester blue
Guest
celf said:
Soul?
I'd go with Given or Ireland. I can understand SWP. If you don't think he's important watch how many times United foul him if he plays. It's almost as if they are told to take turns....
bluetonium
Well-Known Member
Given or Barry. Given for obvious reasons, and Barry because he can run the midfield on his day, enabling our impressive front line to really go to town.