Penalty Taker

[Lowtower]

Be great if Ederson took them, just to piss everyone off.

And free kicks too, Lad could get 10 goals a season.

 

[Stephen230]

Haaland, KDB & Grealish all excellent pen takers and not on last night.

Foden was excellent as was Eddy. Alvarez always good.

Means in a game we will always be fine. Pen shootout was bad luck. We go again.

Grealish has never taken a penalty in a first team match, so not sure there’s any evidence how good he is from the spot.

DeBruyne should be the perfect choice but he’s missed two of the nine he’s taken for City and wasn’t too convincing on some of the ones that did go in from memory.

 

[Coljj]

Feel like if we ever put Ederson on pens the bar would set even higher and less would be awarded as a result.

 

[Stewadda#]

Bring Franny Lee out of retirement.

He never messed about, kept the goal net repairers in business for years,

Ermm I have some bad news for you mate.

 

[Toney’s bookie]

There is a legend within the training ground that Ederson is the best penalty taker in the team.

After tonight, I've seen enough. Make it happen.

Presumably the reason Eddie took the penalty he did was because at that point we simply couldn’t afford to miss so he had to. I imagine we’d have worked our way through a list but kept him in the back pocket until a pen came along to either win it or keep us in it.

 

[jamielowndes]

Presumably the reason Eddie took the penalty he did was because at that point we simply couldn’t afford to miss so he had to. I imagine we’d have worked our way through a list but kept him in the back pocket until a pen came along to either win it or keep us in it.

Quite possibly.

Tbf in shootouts if he is as good as believed, it 100% makes sense to have him in the 5.

In a regular game, as much as I want to see it as a long time fan of strange goalkeepers, it's an insane risk and almost always unjustifiable.

 

[Len Rum]

Did we plan and prepare for penalty shoot out last night?
If so, on what basis.
As regards technique one school of thought is that every player that should practice penalties and have an MO that should not be varied in the stress and pressure situation of a shoot out.
Or are players left to decide for themselves on the night?
To me the first option would appear to be the most sensible.
And course on the night the Manager must decide on the technical ability and physical and mental strength of the players available.
I wonder what happened last night?

 

[kun]

Always? Balotelli and Yaya were mustard, did they miss one between them?

Not for City they didn’t. Neither did Elano.

 

[I'm Blue]

Obviously Eddie ain’t gonna take them during a game cos if he missed or it’s saved then it’s a goal the other way.
He should however be training the rest of the team to take them.

 

[eastmanc]

Not for City they didn’t. Neither did Elano.

That Mancini side had a number of great penalty takers. Yaya, Balotelli, Barry, Milner, Nasri and the worse one of the lot and he took the most Sergio. Oh and I forgot Tevez took them as well.

 

[Barney Daniels]

Super cup in August v Sevilla ,community shield in August v arsenal

The one before that was West Ham in the League Cup in 21/22, so lost three of the last four.

 

[MCFC1993]

Obviously Eddie ain’t gonna take them during a game cos if he missed or it’s saved then it’s a goal the other way.
He should however be training the rest of the team to take them.

I think the chance of Eddie missing and them countering is very slim. We should have enough men back to prevent any shot within decent range before he gets back.

His technique under pressure shown he probably should take them. I suppose playing out from the back accurately almost represents the pressure of taking a penalty, which is why he might be so good.

 

[Craig]

I think the chance of Eddie missing and them countering is very slim. We should have enough men back to prevent any shot within decent range before he gets back.

Hit technique under pressure shown he probably should take them. I suppose playing out from the back accurately almost represents the pressure of taking a penalty, which is why he might be so good.

Yeah like you say very slim indeed. Most times a pens missed it ends up either a corner or a dead ball. Plus with all the players behind him it would be easy to just commit a foul well up in their half

 

[I'm Blue]

I think the chance of Eddie missing and them countering is very slim. We should have enough men back to prevent any shot within decent range before he gets back.

His technique under pressure shown he probably should take them. I suppose playing out from the back accurately almost represents the pressure of taking a penalty, which is why he might be so good.

The words ‘typical City’ spring to mind : )

 

[RayCTID]

I think the chance of Eddie missing and them countering is very slim. We should have enough men back to prevent any shot within decent range before he gets back.

His technique under pressure shown he probably should take them. I suppose playing out from the back accurately almost represents the pressure of taking a penalty, which is why he might be so good.

It is still not worth the risk. We still have a reliable penalty taker in Erling Haaland (providing we do get a rare one).