PFA nominations are out

Salah will win it by one vote, the one Kev gave him.

Salah has helped the scousers win 19 games

Kev has had a hand in us winning all of ours

27 in total, there is no competion, Kev should win hands down, if salah wins, it's for goals not all round performance.
 
urban genie said:
Salah has helped the scousers win 19 games

Kev has had a hand in us winning all of ours
Click to expand...

Even as someone who wants Kev to win, this seems more than a bit disingenuous. The best player of the season doesn't have to be in the best team, and 1 player in an 11 man team can't do everything.

Liverpool not winning the league doesn't mean Salah shouldn't be considered for POTY.
 
hertsblue said:
Dont you think 24 years old is a bit old for young player of the year
Click to expand...

It's supposed to be under 23's like the youth leagues, but if you are 23 when the season starts and turn 24 they allow it

Thimg it Kane was 24 late July so before.the season started, but after last season so he has been allowed, to me only so he can win it being a world cup year and with no chance of winning the main one.
 
domalino said:
Even as someone who wants Kev to win, this seems more than a bit disingenuous.
Click to expand...

27 wins for us, how many has Kev been a major factor in? Probably all.

Kev along with Silva have powered our midfield to keep us on top spot in fact fern should be on the list imho as well.

Salah has banged in shitloads and be applauded for it, but Kev is a better player all round over this season.

Being top shouldn't guarentee you winning it, yet seasons when Sergio has been top scorer, Yaya and Silva have excelled a player from the league winners has won it instead, because they were top all season.
 
Last edited:
urban genie said:
27 wins for us, how many has Kev been a major factor in? Probably all.

Kev along with Silva have powered our midfield to keep us on top spot in fact fern should be on the list imho as well.

Salah has banged in shitloads and be applauded for it, but Kev is a better player all round over this season.

Being top shouldn't guarentee you winning it, yet seasons when Sergio has been top scorer, Yaya and Silva have excelled a player from the league winners has won it instead, because they were top all season.
Click to expand...

So you know that being in the best team doesn't mean your the best player in the league and yet you're trying to use it as a reason why KDB should win...

Just stick to "I think he's been better" instead of making bad arguments about us being the better team.
 
domalino said:
So you know that being in the best team doesn't mean your the best player in the league and yet you're trying to use it as a reason why KDB should win...

Just stick to "I think he's been better" instead of making bad arguments about us being the better team.
Click to expand...

What? You can be both best player and in the best team.

We are the best team because of Kevs performances* he has been the major influence on our season and created numerous passes/chances that have won us games.

So this time yes he deserves it because we are top and because he is better than salah all round this season and the best player in the league.


*that's not taking away from rest of the team that have been excellent also.

Salah has be excellent also, and if he keeps this form up will surely win it another season
 
01cravend said:
Sane being up for player of the season surely make him a shoe-in for young player?

Ohh there's 24 year old(before the start of the season) Kane in the young category LOL
Click to expand...

Kane is 25 in three months and nominated for YPOTY....quite ridiculous.
 
citytill1die84 said:
Salah & Sterling for me I think Kev has dipped quite a lot recently. Sterling deserves it for all the goals and assists he's achieved and hes been much more involved than Sane.

Kane in YPOTY is a joke and Rashford WTF? He hardly plays they really do take the piss.
Click to expand...

Sane is more flash so catches the eye and sticks in the mind more.. it's why Hazard is so revered
 
01cravend said:
That's not individual performance is it...the rest of our team and manager played quite the part in that
Click to expand...

So who gave the ball to Salah then it’s a team game kdb goals and assists made the difference. It’s a tight call who wins it but kdb has contributed more for us and winning trophies.
 
waspish said:
So who gave the ball to Salah then it’s a team game kdb goals and assists made the difference. It’s a tight call who wins it but kdb has contributed more for us and winning trophies.
Click to expand...

De Bruyne - 7 goals 15 assists
Salah - 29 goals 9 assists. 3 goals away from having the best scoring season in premier league history(38 games) and he's a winger

Salah been at it all season too compared to Kev who has dropped off fairly dramatically since the new year to the point of which statistically he's only been slightly better than last season(INDIVIDUALLY). No-one thought he was the best player in the league last season?(rightly or wrongly he wasn't even on the shortlist for the award).
 
Don't give a shite about who wins these awards, it's all show and no substance as proved by various City legends never winning them. Give everything to Salah, we're winning a double and Pep will get beat to MOTY by a backward thinking Englishman......that'll show Pep he can't come here playing great football!
 
01cravend said:
De Bruyne - 7 goals 15 assists
Salah - 29 goals 9 assists. 3 goals away from having the best scoring season in premier league history(38 games) and he's a winger

Salah been at it all season too compared to Kev who has dropped off fairly dramatically since the new year to the point of which statistically he's only been slightly better than last season(INDIVIDUALLY). No-one thought he was the best player in the league last season?(rightly or wrongly he wasn't even on the shortlist for the award).
Click to expand...

Yeah said he has been brilliant and if he gets it fair do’s but being the best needs some candy at the end of the season for me.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top