Financial fair play should be pretty simple.
- Concerned about club solvency? Then clubs shouldn't be allowed incur huge debts, so punish the indebted clubs and restrict their spending (but that might not suit some of the elite). City don’t have any big debts.
- Concerned about future losses, and clubs committing to long term player contracts at huge salaries, without certainty about future funding? Then any clubs doing that need to show the sustainability of future revenue, maybe even assuming no champions league qualification. I’m not sure any elite club would accept that restriction. City could get the expenditure underwritten by Mansour I suppose, but if you’re genuinely worried about the solvency of clubs, that shouldn't be an issue, a good thing even?
- Lastly, if you’re genuinely concerned about "financial doping" and a level playing field, then salary caps and transfer spending limits are the obvious way to go. Can’t see Bayern Munich with their 9 consecutive titles or Juventus with 9 out of 10, or PSG with 8 of the last 9, would be too happy with the idea of any kind of domestic financial equality, or even a slight levelling of it. Madrid and Barca wouldn’t like being restricted in their ability to blow away the competition in Spain.
It’s somehow been deemed far more logical to impose a set of rules based on the existing revenue of the elite super clubs, the big earners are protected, because the upstarts can never invest enough to become as big and successful as them. The most vociferous proponents of these type of rules are supporters of those traditional big clubs, they are numerous and loud, and all over the media.
But City “signed up to the rules”, so they have to abide by them? What was our alternative? The competition is rigged, but you need to be in it.
I’ve no doubt we massively bent and probably even broke the rules, some of our sponsorship deals just don’t make commercial sense, I’ve no doubt owner-funded cash was poured in. But I don’t care, I hope we broke them, as often and as badly as we were able to get away with, otherwise the existing cartel would have succeed in keeping us down, mid-table at best, where we belonged. We don’t need lectures about financial probity from anybody at Bayern Munich, Real Madrid, Barcelona, Chelsea or Manchester United.