Played for City but never should have

[Ballymagash Blue]

Bobby Shinton
Stuart Lee
Barry Silkman
Terry Park
Perry Suckling
Peter Bodak

I seem to recall that Stuart Lee was a big City fan. Was one of the 8,000 v Swindon (or so he claimed, and no real reason to doubt him).

 

[NQCitizen]

Anybody bought in the transfer window from hell (12/13)
Scott Sinclair
Jack rodwell
Maicon
Javi garcia
Nastasic (50/50)

My controversial opinion is Javi Garcia would have looked great under Pep.

 

[flinty1975]

Laurent Charvet, Michael Frontzek, 2 of the worst full backs I’ve seen closely followed by Jason Van Blerk

 

[Pubteam Lomas]

Jason Van Blerk

I used to call him Skippy. Cos of the noise fans mad when he was on the team sheet!!!!!!!!!
(one for the older fans)

 

[Abattoir Blue]

He is an utter **** and bad mouths us to this day. A horrible utter ****

He also has tried to rewrite history, claiming he didn't celebrate when we (and he) beat that lot at Maine Road in 2002. Yes you did lad!

 

[bridgeblue]

Maybe I should have explained myself better.
Not players who were not good enough to play for city. There is an almost endless list of those.
I mean players who never should have been allowed to wear our shirt because of their previous.
I’ve had a drink so maybe not coming across as I mean to.

Lampard

Lampard was good for us during his one season never let us down, he remembers his time with us fondly and he has my total respect for his professionalism during that season

 

[Sky Blue Thinking]

Adrian Heath, never seen a less talented forward, and yes I include Tony Cunningham

Also from the same era, Wayne Clarke

 

[Sky Blue Thinking]

McManaman and Fowler are two of the worst for me. They never liked us, never appreciate anything about the club, and seem to resent our recent history due to our title dominance over Liverpool.

Even though they were both Everton fans as kids

 

[Stoned Rose]

Maybe I should have explained myself better.
Not players who were not good enough to play for city. There is an almost endless list of those.
I mean players who never should have been allowed to wear our shirt because of their previous.
I’ve had a drink so maybe not coming across as I mean to.

Lampard

Are you out on the ale with @urban genie ?

 

[Tarzan Pancake]

Even though they were both Everton fans as kids

It happens with players. Peter Reid was a Liverpool fan, David May was a City fan and seems to hate us now. Players have different loyalties than fans.

 

[mcfcphil]

This thread could be longer than the 115 charges thread

 

[Man_City_Loyal]

Some may say some of our current players!

 

[jamesha]

Can't agree with Fowler.

Much like Milner in that you can track his hatred for United via the fact that played for City, Liverpool, and Leeds.

I definitely agree as his effort for City was way below what it should have been given how much he was paid. He might not have liked United and tried hard in the games against them but that just highlights to me how much he was coasting through other games.
I don't think Milner particularly hated United and he always put a shift in when he was at City.

 

[asahartford1]

Michael Walsh. End of Story

 

[Micky Blue]

Andy (sorry andrew) Cole

He scored goals for us but at the end of the day he’s a rag and couldn’t jump ship quick enough.
He didn’t care about the club, just wanted to stay in the north west and wanted the pay day.

 

[jimharri]

Maybe I should have explained myself better.
Not players who were not good enough to play for city. There is an almost endless list of those.
I mean players who never should have been allowed to wear our shirt because of their previous.
I’ve had a drink so maybe not coming across as I mean to.

Lampard

Going on a certain thread yesterday, having a pre thread drink or 5 seems to be mandatory.

 

[jimharri]

Who the hell is Terry Park? I can remember the vast majority of our players (both good and shite), but his name escapes me.

 

[East Level 2]

Andy (sorry andrew) Cole

He scored goals for us but at the end of the day he’s a rag and couldn’t jump ship quick enough.
He didn’t care about the club, just wanted to stay in the north west and wanted the pay day.

Cole wasn't a rag he just played for them. And he was about the only player who could get the best out of Darius bloody Vassell.

 

[I'm not really here]

Samaras

 

[citymad]

Adrian Heath, never seen a less talented forward, and yes I include Tony Cunningham

Steve Kinsey likes this comment.