Player ratings - Barcelona (a)

R R

Ric

Administrator
Joined
22 May 2004
Messages
51,043
Started doing player ratings on the main site, when I have time at least, so thought it'd be interesting to get other people's ratings after games. For what it's worth, these are mine for tonight:

Bravo 4
Zabaleta 5
Stones 5
Otamendi 6
Kolarov 5
Fernandinho 5
Gundogan 5
Silva 6
Nolito 6
Sterling 7
De Bruyne 6

Caballero 6
Clichy 5
Aguero 5

Unduly harsh, or overly generous?
 
Ric said:
Started doing player ratings on the main site, when I have time at least, so thought it'd be interesting to get other people's ratings after games. For what it's worth, these are mine for tonight:

Bravo 4
Zabaleta 5
Stones 5
Otamendi 6
Kolarov 5
Fernandinho 5
Gundogan 5
Silva 6
Nolito 6
Sterling 7
De Bruyne 6

Caballero 6
Clichy 5
Aguero 5

Unduly harsh, or overly generous?
Click to expand...

Bit harsh on Otamendi, Gundogan to me, also thought Zab was fine until his injury!
 
I love Kev as much as any city fan and desperately want to see him doing well but he looses possession far too easily.. it was a frustrating game for Kev.. really could not influence the game like he can and should.. wish he could perform the way he did against the rags more consistently :(
 
Tough night against the best team on the planet.

Not nice seeing us conceding 4 goals, but we take it on the chin and hopefully we move on.

We have to beat Southampton on Sunday otherwise that would be 5 games without a win, in all competions.

As always, what will be will be!!
 
Bravo - 0
Zabaleta - 5
Otamendi - 7
Stones - 4
Kolarov - 4
Fernandinho - 5
Gundogan - 6
Silva - 5
Sterling - 7
Nolito - 6
De Bruyne - 6
 
Bravo - 0
Zabaleta - 4
Otamendi - 7
Stones - 3
Kolarov - 3
Fernandinho - 5
Gundogan - 6
Silva - 4
Sterling - 7
Nolito - 6
De Bruyne - 5
 
Bravo 4
Zab 6
Otamendi 6
Stones 4
Kolarov 4
Fernandinho 5
Gundogan 6
Silva 6
De Bruyne 6
Sterling 7
Nolito 6

Willy 5
Clichy 4
Aguero 4

Looked totally overawed mostly.
 
Bravo 3
Zabaleta 5
Stones 5
Otamendi 7
Kolarov 5
Fernandinho 5
Gundogan 5
Silva 5
Nolito 4
Sterling 7
De Bruyne 6

Caballero 6
Clichy 5
Aguero 5
 
Up to the Bravo cock-up I would have given most of them a 7, Sterling an 8 and Silva & Kolorov 5.

Bravo then drops to Zero, Sterling stays at 8 and the rest go down to 3.

There is a lack of fight and bottle that needs putting right quickly.
 
Bravo - 6
Zabaleta - 3
Otamendi - 5
Stones - 5
Kolarov - 5
Fernandinho - 5
Gundogan - 6
Silva -6
Sterling - 9
Nolito - 7
De Bruyne - 6
 
we were a match for them for the first hour so I think some of them ratings are a bit harsh but each to their own.
 
Bravo 4 - played well until a game changing mistake.
Zabaleta 5 - coped better than expected.
Stones 4 - worst game for us in my opinion, some slack passes & poor defending for a few of their chances.
Otamendi 7 - at CB he was an absolute rock. Once switched to RB he, unsurprisingly, struggled more.
Kolarov 4 - thought he was poor again, out of position on numerous occasions, some poor passing, gave away the penalty.
Fernandinho 5 - didn't do mass amounts wrong but wasn't a massive influence either.
Gundogan 6 - one of his more influential games for us, but a mistake that cost a goal.
Silva 4 - didn't get involved enough. No notable mistakes, but no notable influence on the game.
Nolito 7 - thought he was great until getting subbed, held the ball up fantastically & carved out a couple of decent chances for us.
Sterling 7.5 - best player for us in the second half.
De Bruyne 6 - played decent, plenty of good runs but final ball/shot just off the mark today.

Caballero 6 - not sure about the first goal he conceded, but a good penalty save. Have to say I fear next week against Barca with him playing out from the back.
Clichy 5 - not much to note.
Aguero 5 - not much to note.
 
Bravo - 6
Zabaleta - 4
Otamendi - 7
Stones - 6
Kolarov - 4
Fernandinho - 6
Gundogan - 6
Silva -4
Sterling - 9
Nolito - 6
De Bruyne - 6
 
BlueMedic said:
Bravo 4 - played well until a game changing mistake.
Zabaleta 5 - coped better than expected.
Stones 4 - worst game for us in my opinion, some slack passes & poor defending for a few of their chances.
Otamendi 7 - at CB he was an absolute rock. Once switched to RB he, unsurprisingly, struggled more.
Kolarov 4 - thought he was poor again, out of position on numerous occasions, some poor passing, gave away the penalty.
Fernandinho 5 - didn't do mass amounts wrong but wasn't a massive influence either.
Gundogan 6 - one of his more influential games for us, but a mistake that cost a goal.
Silva 4 - didn't get involved enough. No notable mistakes, but no notable influence on the game.
Nolito 7 - thought he was great until getting subbed, held the ball up fantastically & carved out a couple of decent chances for us.
Sterling 7.5 - best player for us in the second half.
De Bruyne 6 - played decent, plenty of good runs but final ball/shot just off the mark today.

Caballero 6 - not sure about the first goal he conceded, but a good penalty save. Have to say I fear next week against Barca with him playing out from the back.
Clichy 5 - not much to note.
Aguero 5 - not much to note.
Click to expand...

Good comments, especially Silva who gives that kind of peripheral performance every time we play Barca or Bayern etc.
 
First half

Bravo - 7
Zabaleta - 6
Otamendi - 8
Stones - 6
Kolarov - 7
Fernandinho - 7
Gundogan - 8
Silva - 8
Sterling - 8
Nolito - 8
De Bruyne - 6


Second half

Bravo - 1
Zabaleta - 3
Otamendi - 6
Stones - 2
Kolarov - 5
Fernandinho - 5
Gundogan - 6
Silva - 6
Sterling - 6
Nolito - 3
De Bruyne - 4
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top