Player Ratings

[Dax777]

Hart: 9
Zaba: 9.5
Kolarov: 4.5
Lescott: 6
Kompany: 6.5
NDJ: 6.5
Barry: 7.5
Yaya; 8
Silva; 8
A.J: 6
Balo; 5.5


Milner; 7
Dzeko; 6
Viera; 5.5

MOTM: Pablo Zabaletta. That was how I saw it.

 

[Bobby4Mayor]

Hart: 8
Zaba: 9
Kolarov: 7
Lescott: 8
Kompany: 6.5
NDJ: 7.5
Barry: 7
Yaya; 7
Silva; 9
A.J: 6
Balo; 5


Milner; 8
Dzeko; 5.5
Viera; 5.5

Silva was exceptional for me, involved in every attack.

 

[MCFC BOB]

Hart 6 - good save from Keane, but was too slow when deciding where to kick and throw the ball.

Zabaleta 8 - once again, another passionate and all round good performance from Pablo.

Kompany 7 - didn't have much to deal with, but did well when called into action.

Lescott 7 - was at fault for West Ham's goal, but dealt well with everything else.

Kolarov 6 - slow to get forward and made two mistakes that could have lead to awful outcomes for City.

De Jong 7 - great finish for his goal, City missed his bite and passion when he went off.

Yaya Toure 6 - quiet, but got on with his game well.

Barry 7 - exceptional in the first half, let down by his second half performance, was subbed for Dzeko.

Adam Johnson 6 - good start, closed out of the game.

Silva 7 - good game as ever from Spanish Dave, but I just wish he would have a bit more confidence in shooting positions.

Balotelli 6 - good first half, poor second half.

Dzeko 6 - cameo wasn't effective, but stung Green's gloves once or twice.

Milner 8 - excellent, best game I've seen him play in a while, got stuck in and looked dangerous.

Vieira N/A - came on too late to be rated.

 

[TheSituation]

Hart - 7

Zaba - 7.5
Kompany - 7
Lescott - 5.5
Kolarov - 6.5

de Jong - 7.5
Barry - 7
Yaya - 6

Silva - 7.5
Balotelli - 6
Johnson - 5

 

[LoveCity]

Hart - 7

Zabaleta - 8
Kompany - 7
Lescott - 7.5
Kolarov - 5

De Jong - 7
Barry - 7
Yaya - 8

Silva - 8
Balotelli - 6
Johnson - 6.5

Subs:

Dzeko - 6
Milner - 7.5
Vieira - N/A

 

[Ntini77]

Surprised to see the low ratings for Yaya. He was ace yesterday.

 

[Robinho's Subbuteo]

Hart - 7

Zaba - 7.5
Kompany - 7
Lescott - 5.5
Kolarov - 6.5

de Jong - 7.5
Barry - 7
Yaya - 6

Silva - 7.5
Balotelli - 6
Johnson - 5

Did you even watch the game? Kolarov rated higher than Lescott and Yaya?????

 

[Any1aBlue]

Hart: 9
Zaba: 9.5
Kolarov: 4.5
Lescott: 6
Kompany: 6.5
NDJ: 6.5
Barry: 7.5
Yaya; 8
Silva; 8
A.J: 6
Balo; 5.5


Milner; 7
Dzeko; 6
Viera; 5.5

MOTM: Pablo Zabaletta. That was how I saw it.

well done.............next thread please.

 

[Marvin]

Hart: 9
Zaba: 9.5
Kolarov: 4.5
Lescott: 6
Kompany: 6.5
NDJ: 6.5
Barry: 7.5
Yaya; 8
Silva; 8
A.J: 6
Balo; 5.5


Milner; 7
Dzeko; 6
Viera; 5.5

MOTM: Pablo Zabaletta. That was how I saw it.

Couldn't give Hart a 9 because I remember just the one save from Keane. His distribution was good though.

I'd give Lescott an 8 because he always seemed to be there snuffing out West Ham attacks.

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

Lescott 7 - was at fault for West Ham's goal, but dealt well with everything else.

The fault with the goal lay with the strategy of dragging everyone back to defend a corner. Jole made a decent defensive header that cleared the penalty area by a good margin. By the time the ball was crossed into the area again, Silva was the only one within shouting distance of challenging. The nearest he got was about five yards. I do not know why we insist on having everyone back. Someone standing outside the area by five or six yards would have been able to have challenged that cross.

Yer can nick a goal in the blink of an eye, no matter how crap you are, and Webb yesterday had all the hallmarks of giving West Ham a leg-up.