Players season ratings so far

[lionheart]

No way should Vinnie get a 10 or Tevez a 9-9.5 as they have both had their occasional off-days.

 

[GX Blue]

Goalkeepers:
Hart - 7
Given - 5
Taylor - 0

Defenders:
Vinnie - 9.5
Kolo - 6
Lescott - 6
Richards - 8
Zab - 8
Kolarov - 5
Boateng - 5
Boyata - 6

Midfielders:
AJ - 8
NDJ - 9
Silva - 9
Barry - 7
Viera - 6
Swp - 6
Milner - 6
Yaya - 6

Forwards:
Tevez - 9
Dzeko - 6
Ballotelli - 6
Jo - 2

Vinnie has had about 1 bad game (Wolves Away) and Tevez has had a few where hes not done much so i dont see how anyone can give Tevez higher then Vinnie.
Gave Jo 2 for the Fulham away game or he would have got 1.

 

[Dax777]

And why is AJ an 8?

 

[Akira]

No way should Vinnie get a 10 or Tevez a 9-9.5 as they have both had their occasional off-days.

Every player has their off-days, you just gotta look at their overall contribution to the club and on the pitch. Tevez deserves at least a 9 imo, he scored most of our goals. I don't give players 10 because I don't believe in perfection, but for overall consistency, Vinnie deserves at least a 9.

 

[bluethai]

Keepers:
Hart - 6.5
Given - -
Taylor - -

Defenders:
Kompany - 8.5
Kolo - 6.5
Lescott - 7
Richards - 7
Zabaleta - 8
Kolarov - 4
Boateng - 5.5
Boyata - 5.5

Midfielders:
AJ - 6.5
NDJ - 8
Silva - 9
Barry - 6.5
Viera - 6
Swp - 5
Milner - 5.5
Yaya - 7

Forwards:
Tevez - 9
Dzeko - 6.5
Ballotelli - 6.5
Jo - 5.5

 

[brian the blue]

Keepers:
Hart - 6.5
Given - -
Taylor - -

Defenders:
Kompany - 8.5
Kolo - 6.5
Lescott - 7
Richards - 7
Zabaleta - 7
Kolarov - 6
Boateng - 6
Boyata - 5.5

Midfielders:
AJ - 6.5
NDJ - 8
Silva - 9
Barry - 6
Viera - 6
Swp - 5
Milner - 6
Yaya - 7.5

Forwards:
Tevez - 8.5
Dzeko - 6.5
Balotelli - 7.5
Jo - 5

 

[hitRECORDSam]

Goalkeepers:
Hart - 7
Given - 6
Taylor - 5

Defenders:
Vinnie - 9
Kolo - 8
Lescott - 7
Richards - 8
Zab - 8
Kolarov - 7
Boateng - 5
Boyata - 6

Midfielders:
AJ - 7
NDJ - 9
Silva - 9
Barry - 7
Viera - 6
Swp - 6
Milner - 7
Yaya - 7

Forwards:
Tevez - 9
Dzeko - 6
Ballotelli - 6
Jo - 5

I know I've missed a couple out but these are the main crew.

What do you think? And what are your own ratings?

Far too blinkered. SWP 6? How? What's he done? More like 4

Milner a 7? I forgot he was still with us. 5

Jo hasn't done anything to merit a 1.

Barry is shit. 5

Lescott's come good only recently. 6

Kolarov's a 6, Zab a 7. Your list would suggest we've been brilliant and are challenging for the league when we've underwhelmed.

 

[JoeMercer'sWay]

Hart-7.5
Given-N/A
Taylor-N/A

Zabaleta-8.
Kompany-8.5
Kolo-6.
Lescott-6.
Boyata-4.5.
Kolarov-5.
Boateng-5.
Richards-6.5.

De Jong-8.
Barry-6.5.
Yaya-7.
Vieira-6.
AJ-6.
SWP-4.
Milner-5.
Silva-7.5.

Tevez-9.
Dzeko-5.
Balotelli-5.5.(could do a million miles more for the team).
Jo-0.
Adebayor-6.
Santa Cruz-2.5.

 

[cityslickster]

lescotts performances since being a regular have been far more commanding/less a liability than kolo has been. 7 for Lescott and a 5 for Kolo

 

[DD]

Goalkeepers:
Hart - 7
Given - No mark
Taylor - No mark

Defenders:
Kompany - 9
K.Toure - 7
Lescott - 6
Richards - 7
Zabaleta - 7
Kolarov - 5
Boateng - 5
Boyata - 5

Midfielders:
A.Johnson - 6
De Jong - 8
Silva - 8
Barry - 6
Viera - 4
Wright-Phillips - 4
Milner - 5
Y.Toure - 6

Forwards:
Tevez - 8
Dzeko - 5
Ballotelli - 6
Jo - 4