Wintermute
Member
They were split 50-50 at first. Half of them actually wanted the Heart to have had a more English identity in the first place - in fact, one of the bidding groups for the second Melbourne franchise was campaigning for a team called Melbourne City FC - and half wanted their Heart back. There's occasional talk of some fans abandoning their support over their identity change, but mostly they seem to have just adapted to it. Those who never quite took to the Heart identity were happy with the change, those who did have built a rationale based on vague evidence and specific wording of articles that says the Heart was a different club which ceased to exist when the licence was sold. They can therefore give it their begrudging support as the replacement to Melbourne Heart without having to pretend that the identity of the former has been ripped away by the latter.
That all happened a year ago, though, and they don't mention it much now. After a year of peturbance over the poor squad CFG gave them last season they are feeling somewhat more assuaged by the training facilities CFG have built them, and the higher-level signings they've so far acquired. There is still some lingering resentment that NYCFC gets Pirlo and they get Robbie Koren, but most of them are willing to simply shrug their shoulders and accept it because A) unlike those in New York they have no belief that A-League has any chance of ever becoming a top-level league and therefore they have much lower aspirations and B) because they are willing to accept that the project may take some time and that eventually they will get the star marquees they dream of.
Could not agree more with that post as someone who is apart of that forum and someone who welcomes the CFG takeover (having put up with the previous owners). The only thing I would add is that if Koren actually made an impact (was a passenger last season and looked totally dis interested) then everyone would have a different opinion and would embrace him and perhaps the annoyance of New York getting all the star players would not have been so prevalent. Plus the Villa thing also didnt help, seems like Melbourne Supporters blame New York and New York supporters blame Manchester for that.