Just out of interest, do you think it’s impossible for any of our players to ever be out of form and not worthy of a place in the team? Or do you just live in a utopian world where every player is super awesome and the manager is never wrong as he’s great too, and I will lambast anyone on here who dares criticise a player or the manager?
You see, you then mention about Gundo and Bernie and think oh I will have a pop at people questioning them too, whereas all 3 of these players have deserved
criticism at some point, and as I pulled you on it the other day, this is a forum for discussion of said players. Thats why we are here.
I shall answer your questions in turn.
Players go from "in" form, to "out of" form for a variety of reasons, health, injùry, team formation, psychology, mental well being, are just a few. I do not believe that if a player is not at their best the answer is "Sell". I believe footballers are like water and find their level, as Sterling , Gundogan, Jesus, Stones , Zinchenko, et al have done.
Yes, is the answer to the Guardiola question. He is "undroppable". I think he is a genius. When he goes I doubt we will ever be as good. I thought Pearce , Keegan, Reid, and many more were idiots, I believed I had more football knowledge, I certainly had the same qualifications. Guardiola to me is a football god, and i feel privileged to be able to support the team that he coaches.
Re Gundo and Bernie. If a poster has the right to say, "Sell them", do I not have the right to question that view. It is after all as you say a forum for discussion. So if posters believe, Sterling is shit, or Gundogan is Gash, or Bernardo should be sold, I will continue to highlight that view and agree with Guardiola that they are trying their best.