Rank all Pep signings from best to worst

[LangleyBlue1970]

Whilst officially he wasn’t managing when he joined, KDB was, for me, a Pep signing with Pep knowing he would be joining a year later. So he is number one.

Unfortunately for Phillips, pound for pound he has to be the worst.

 

[gazinho]

Any list without that fucking clown without arms we stuck in net at the very bottom of it is incorrect

 

[Man_City_Loyal]

Best is:

Mendy
Phillips
Bravo

Worst of the list:

Rodri
Erling
Bernie

 

[The Norfolk Blue]

Lets have some actual fun..

IMHO my list:

Rodri
Erling
Mahrez
Ilkay
Bernardo

Stones
Ruben
Walker
Ederson
Laporte

Ake
Marmoush
Julian
Sane
Khusanov

Josko
Nico
Akanji
Doku
Jesus

Savinho
Danilo
Carson
Cancelo
Zinny

Nunes
Grealish
Gomez
Ferran
Bravo

Kovacic
Steffen
Mendy
Angelino
Nolito
Philips

I left out Vitor Reis and Maximo Perrone because not enough of an impact yet to judge them.

What's your list?

Kova much higher up for me, definitely above Nunes, Bravo & Carson who belong in the bottom bracket.

 

[KS55]

You could argue that Pep made no signings but Txiki did. Pep would say that.
“I am not the manager. I have to use the players the club gives me.”

 

[Uncle Wally One Ball]

Lets have some actual fun..

IMHO my list:

Rodri
Erling
Mahrez
Ilkay
Bernardo

Stones
Ruben
Walker
Ederson
Laporte

Ake
Marmoush
Julian
Sane
Khusanov

Josko
Nico
Akanji
Doku
Jesus

Savinho
Danilo
Carson
Cancelo
Zinny

Nunes
Grealish
Gomez
Ferran
Bravo

Kovacic
Steffen
Mendy
Angelino
Nolito
Philips

I left out Vitor Reis and Maximo Perrone because not enough of an impact yet to judge them.

What's your list?

Sounds like the opposite of fun to me, Im out

 

[Yankunian]

Lets have some actual fun..

IMHO my list:

Rodri
Erling
Mahrez
Ilkay
Bernardo

Stones
Ruben
Walker
Ederson
Laporte

Ake
Marmoush
Julian
Sane
Khusanov

Josko
Nico
Akanji
Doku
Jesus

Savinho
Danilo
Carson
Cancelo
Zinny

Nunes
Grealish
Gomez
Ferran
Bravo

Kovacic
Steffen
Mendy
Angelino
Nolito
Philips

I left out Vitor Reis and Maximo Perrone because not enough of an impact yet to judge them.

What's your list?

personally feel Zack Steffen probably doesn't get enough credit , was superb during the 2020/21 Carabao Cup for us and came in a few games for Ederson during our winning run that season including the win away at Chelsea, feel he is only remembered for his shocker at Wembley v Liverpool definitely made bigger impacts than Carson, Bravo & Nunes also feel Kovacic is harsh

 

[BigJoe#1]

Wot no Erling

Pffffffff

Knownouts

 

[Gorbachev]

Lets have some actual fun..

IMHO my list:

Rodri
Erling
Mahrez
Ilkay
Bernardo

Stones
Ruben
Walker
Ederson
Laporte

Ake
Marmoush
Julian
Sane
Khusanov

Josko
Nico
Akanji
Doku
Jesus

Savinho
Danilo
Carson
Cancelo
Zinny

Ortega
Nunes
Grealish
Gomez
Ferran
Bravo

Kovacic
Steffen
Mendy
Angelino
Nolito
Philips

I left out Vitor Reis and Maximo Perrone because not enough of an impact yet to judge them.

What's your list?

List is pretty much spot on in regards to the tiers.

Cancelo should be higher though for me.

He became a FIFA World XI fullback whilst with us and despite his utterly poor attitude, he was immense for us.

Got around £21m in a sale plus the numerous loan fees for him as well so we would have recouped a good £30m-£35m back for him back.

 

[Johnny Mars Bar]

Lets have some actual fun..

IMHO my list:

Rodri
Erling
Mahrez
Ilkay
Bernardo

Stones
Ruben
Walker
Ederson
Laporte

Ake
Marmoush
Julian
Sane
Khusanov

Josko
Nico
Akanji
Doku
Jesus

Savinho
Danilo
Carson
Cancelo
Zinny

Ortega
Nunes
Grealish
Gomez
Ferran
Bravo

Kovacic
Steffen
Mendy
Angelino
Nolito
Philips

I left out Vitor Reis and Maximo Perrone because not enough of an impact yet to judge them.

What's your list?

Ortega down there with Nunes, are you smoking crack?