Referees/Officials 2017/18 performances

[Nelinho]

How Mike Dean did today:

Game 3:, Bournemouth away: No freekick for G. Jesus at 17 minutes, No freekick after failed advantage, Defore offside (no flag), no freekick for G. Jesus after two footed tackle from behind from Ake, Bournemouth player dives and gets freekick, Jesus gets fouled through on goal and Ake only gets a yellow, No corner for City after Bournemouth deflection of Jesus shot, After fouls D. Silva but no foul given, no freekick for Fernandinho & penalty shout for B. Silva right after not given, Defore dives and gets freekick, Wrongful freekick to Bournemouth for non-foul by Danilo, Wrongful offside on Sterling, No freekick at the 45th minute, Ake has committed two yellow card fouls and one red card foul in the first half but hasn’t received a single card of verbal warning, King dives and gets freekick, Cook gives out a red card worthy tackle on G. Jesus but Mike Dean doesn’t even give a freekick, The bournemouth wall was too close and kept moving forward refs did nothing even though there were complaints, Begovic wastes time a 3rd time & Dean tells him to hurry up a 2nd time, Wrongful offside against G. Jesus, Fernandinho gets fouled by two players & Dean does nothing which results in a shot that hits the post, Adam Smith dives after a light touch by Jesus and gets a freekick, No throw in for City which lead to Bournemouth attack, Harry Arter wastes time by pretending to be hurt, Defoe dives & gets freekick Otamendi yellow carded, Bournemouth gets a corner wrongfully, Aguero fouled by 2 player at the same time but no penalty, Aguero fouled by two players again no freekick, Cook not sent off for booting G. Jesus in the back of the head, Bournemouth gets wrongful throw in, De bruyne fouled Bournemouth counters which results in Mendy yellow card, Otamendi fouled Mike Dean says it’s on the ball (it wasn’t), G. Jesus wrongfully called offside, David Silva foul but no penalty, The Bourne mouth wall too close again on City freekick, Bournemouth players wastes time by being fake hurt, Arter dives and Sterling gets a yellow card, Afobe wastes time by pretending to be in pain resulting in a sub, Sterling gets red cared for celebrating a goal,

Keep it up man. I wouldn't agree 100% but that's hardly the point. This is very useful, really appreciate it. Thanks!

 

[Nelinho]

can't appeal it, two yellows..

I see. Thanks!

 

[FogBlueInSanFran]

I bet all other fans are bemoaning the amount of time added on.

Just on some other sites -- indeed that's exactly what they're doing, calling for Dean to be sanctioned for adding on time. Not a mention of the Ake call.

To be fair, even the most aggressive City haters think the red for Sterling was unfair.

 

[goatinho]

Yet another game where the game-changing decisions go against us. 3 games out of 3 now. Gonna break last season's record at this rate

1. Wrongly disallowed 2nd half goal at Brighton
2. Walker joke red
3. Ake not sent off
4. Sterling joke red

cook on jesus ....twice.

im really getting to the point where it is laughable.
i have a mate whos a west brom fan and we have spoke about all this before and he text my saying wow you have opened my eyes

 

[malg]

Not possible if they were watching the game. The 5 mins we're held up at 90.58 because Dean spent the first minute lecturing the managers and then they had a three minute injury 30 seconds later. You didn't watch the game did you? I'm sure you said so in the post match thread.

Weren't you defending Dean and the "new ruling on penalties" after the Stoke away game this time last year?

Why try and defend what everyone else saw when you didn't even see it?

Behave yourself. I'm just saying what opposition fans will be saying.

 

[Totnes Blue]

Are there in fact,any decent sensible referees at all? Dean today was horrendous,why is this the norm?

 

[Rammy Blue]

Joke of a display.

The biggest problem is that we've had 2 horrific reffing displays on the trot, doesn't bode well for the rest of the season.

 

[malg]

Just on some other sites -- indeed that's exactly what they're doing, calling for Dean to be sanctioned for adding on time. Not a mention of the Ake call.

To be fair, even the most aggressive City haters think the red for Sterling was unfair.

Fucking joke, but as someone posted elsewhere, the ref will think he's had a good game and got it all right. Two joke reds in two games. One thing is for sure, Rashford doesn't get that red, or Kane.

 

[The blue phantom]

Not possible if they were watching the game. The 5 mins we're held up at 90.58 because Dean spent the first minute lecturing the managers and then they had a three minute injury 30 seconds later. You didn't watch the game did you? I'm sure you said so in the post match thread.

Weren't you defending Dean and the "new ruling on penalties" after the Stoke away game this time last year?

Why try and defend what everyone else saw when you didn't even see it?

So whats your theory then?..As all you do is fuckin shout down anyone who has a different opinion to you.

I mean two days ago you said Gerrard. Lampard. Wright and fellow ex pros were being paid at cup draws to stop us.

 

[Dave Ewing's Back 'eader]

We had another clown at the EDS game last night. Their No9 had about four or five chances to crock someone, then a couple of tellings off, and then finally a booking. We had a couple of players booked straight after the foul. No chance, no lecture. Booking!

I also think that there isn't the flimsiest comparison with two bookings one for, say, legging someone as they go past, and crocking them with a tackle that is more venom than fairness and two bookings for kicking the ball away and over-celebrating. The refs seem to ooze authority when Dean books Aguero for removing his shirt (can't remember when that was!!) or when someone bangs in a winner at the death and dives into the crowd! They never seem to get lectured for kicking the ball away as some seem to be spoken to for crocking and attempting to maim!

It's always struck me that refs pray for a ball kicked away or someone jumping into the crowd so they can keep up the yellow card count but despair if someone is hell bent on 90mins of robust tackling for which they should receive a yellow on the first go but don't get one until the 86th min.