richards or zabaleta?

[supercity36]

for me zaba

oh and please dont bring up buying a new RB (i know we would all love maicon...) but if you had to choose?

ill keep a tally after each page (assuming people actually post)

 

[Lmarkham-blueblood]

agreed zab for now but micah if he gets to be the player that everyone says he was going to be in the 07-08 season then him by a bloody mile (i do still love zab though)

 

[dw7]

zab

 

[tomb17]

Zabaleta any day, he's a better defender than richards and better going forward. The past 12 months Richards hasn't been getter better, hes getting worse

 

[yatesy94]

Richards anyday i know he can return to his old form...FINGERS CROSSED

I just dont rate Zab hes alright as a bit of energy to bring on the last 20 minutes but hes nowhere near the player Corluka was and i've always said that since day one.

 

[superblue91]

zab for me 2,,richards has put far 2 much beef on 4 me and his passing is awfull,but hes young i suppose,,but defo taken back steps 4 me in the last 12-16 months or so

 

[blue1969]

Richards. since the 'fall out' with Hughes he started to pull his finger out. Prefer Zab in MF

 

[sam the drummer]

Currently Zab for me. Better defender and can put in a great cross e.g. Fulham

Richards is still young, so has time on his side and he has great pace

 

[dario2739]

Zab hands down for me - better defender and far better going forward - plus the guy always gives 110%

 

[bluwes]

Zab for me, but I must say I was impressed with Richards performance in the U21's.