Scott Carson signs a new one year deal (Pg 11)

OK, he's 'a leader in the dressing room', but hugely disappointing if he'll be the third choice keeper, instead of giving a youngster a chance. Better to sign to him as a coach & register him as a player for emergency situations that meant none of the three were available.
 
Ghost of 76 said:
OK, he's 'a leader in the dressing room', but hugely disappointing if he'll be the third choice keeper, instead of giving a youngster a chance. Better to sign to him as a coach & register him as a player for emergency situations that meant none of the three were available.
Click to expand...
What use is sticking a young lad as 3rd choice when he either needs to be playing with his age group or out on loan.
 
Coatigan said:
Pedigree, experience, good-guy.
Click to expand...





2003–2005		Leeds United3(0)
2005–2008Liverpool4(0)
2006→ Sheffield Wednesday (loan)9(0)
2006–2007→ Charlton Athletic (loan)36(0)
2007–2008→ Aston Villa (loan)35(0)
2008–2011West Bromwich Albion110(0)
2011–2013Bursaspor63(0)
2013–2015Wigan Athletic50(0)
2015–2021Derby County158(0)
2019–2021→ Manchester City (loan)1(0)
2021–Manchester City0(0)

Pedigree?
Experience?
Good guy, He may very well be a "good guy" but I like a bit more than he`s a good guy to convince me Scott Carson who`s played 1 more game than I have during is City career is worthy of a squad place.

If you could explain to or indeed can anyone explain to me the pedigree and experience bit please, because I`m at a loss to understand what Scott offers.
 
r.soleofsalford said:

2003–2005		Leeds United3(0)
2005–2008Liverpool4(0)
2006→ Sheffield Wednesday (loan)9(0)
2006–2007→ Charlton Athletic (loan)36(0)
2007–2008→ Aston Villa (loan)35(0)
2008–2011West Bromwich Albion110(0)
2011–2013Bursaspor63(0)
2013–2015Wigan Athletic50(0)
2015–2021Derby County158(0)
2019–2021→ Manchester City (loan)1(0)
2021–Manchester City0(0)

Pedigree?
Experience?
Good guy, He may very well be a "good guy" but I like a bit more than he`s a good guy to convince me Scott Carson who`s played 1 more game than I have during is City career.

If you could explain to or indeed can anyone explain to me the pedigree and experience bit please, because I`m at a loss to understand what Scott offers.
Click to expand...

His goals per game record is shocking.... cant see the point.
 
r.soleofsalford said:

2003–2005		Leeds United3(0)
2005–2008Liverpool4(0)
2006→ Sheffield Wednesday (loan)9(0)
2006–2007→ Charlton Athletic (loan)36(0)
2007–2008→ Aston Villa (loan)35(0)
2008–2011West Bromwich Albion110(0)
2011–2013Bursaspor63(0)
2013–2015Wigan Athletic50(0)
2015–2021Derby County158(0)
2019–2021→ Manchester City (loan)1(0)
2021–Manchester City0(0)

Pedigree?
Experience?
Good guy, He may very well be a "good guy" but I like a bit more than he`s a good guy to convince me Scott Carson who`s played 1 more game than I have during is City career.

If you could explain to or indeed can anyone explain to me the pedigree and experience bit please, because I`m at a loss to understand what Scott offers.
Click to expand...

He has medals, including the PL and CL.

He has been in the game nearly 2 decades.

Hence, pedigree and experience. Good guy we already agree with.

I don't pick them btw, if it were uo to me the squad space would go to an outfield player. But that is my guess as to why the club chose to sign him.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Unread Posts

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
✖
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.