Shay Given

[juhanni]

No he is starting to dominate the box, we dont need Hart or anybody else !

 

[brenda]

do you mean those 2 punches in the last match!! This is the only position that worries me today as we know he will stay firmly on his line for the whole match and well I'm worried

 

[blueonblue]

Hart is a far better goalie than Given, what Given is, is a shot stopper who aint bad at goalkeeping.

Any Newcastle fan will tell you the same thing after the many years they had him, and is the reason no top club ever tried to sign him untill the numpty came along, a signing that was not needed as Hart has shown at brum.

 

[Sky Blue]

No he is starting to dominate the box, we dont need Hart or anybody else !

Oh really ?

 

[blundellbluemoon]

why does nobody blame given for there goal he could have put that ball anywere under no pressure at all. and he puts it out for a delap special givens fault end off. no throw in no goal we win 1-0.

 

[Bill]

without him newcastle went down. end of thread.

 

[uberblue]

Big Joe greatest goalkeeper of all time in the history of the world

 

[brenda]

given terrible again today

 

[blue ranger]

Would personally take Hart over Given. His distribution is much better than Givens and at least he will come for the odd cross. Given is a goal line keeper, and with our central defenders that isnt a great help.

Admit Given is probably the best shot stopper in the league, but Joe Hart is the future of Manchester City and we should bring him back in the summer and make him number 1. Dont want to let him go and end up keeping an ageing Given.

 

[nikusha]

Would personally take Hart over Given. His distribution is much better than Givens and at least he will come for the odd cross. Given is a goal line keeper, and with our central defenders that isnt a great help.

Admit Given is probably the best shot stopper in the league, but Joe Hart is the future of Manchester City and we should bring him back in the summer and make him number 1. Dont want to let him go and end up keeping an ageing Given.

sometimes i think that you guys are just ungrateful!Given is the best in our team.I'm sure you liked him when he saved the penalty kick against Chelsea

shame on you people