Sky MNF 17/18

[Churchlawtonblue]

I think the analysis from Caragher and Neville on both United and City is fair and interesting. They've done their homework and the analysis is thoughtful. Probably the best there is on radio/TV

I have to agree

 

[MCFC1993]

I thought the winter analysis was fair (although Neville said it more in hope for this season).

We're averaging 2.8 points a game this season though, which means a dip over winter won't affect us as bad as it has done in the past 2 seasons.

Other than that, just more praise.

 

[waspish]

Think rags watching this will be lifted by rat boy agenda

 

[scousemanc]

Well @remember arthur mann I listen to and watch a lot of pundits and in my opinion these two are very good. Tonight I found all their points interesting. It wasn't about Huddersfield - that was last week - it's about this week and the current state of the teams. I only speak for myself and offer an opinion, and my opinion is that these are two of the best.

 

[city saint]

to be fair they gave us lots of praise but ratboy obviously hoping against hope our boys go soft on a rainy day in stoke.they did say were playing at an amazing standard but I don't suppose they could say much else.pretty fair though to be honest.

 

[Churchlawtonblue]

Straw clutching a specialty for Ratboy it seems, no mention of all the other contenders having to play in winter, in fact his glorious hoof ballers got turned over in such circumstances against Huddersfield not mentioned of course.

I think he was referring to whether City can maintain this level of football in those months. To be fair he said it was the best he has ever seen, at a different level. The stats are astonishing. I think he is right it's a valid question. Its a very tough time of year for the reasons he listed. And most of us on here have probably thought the same. How long can we maintain playing at this incredible level. I know I have.

 

[waspish]

So what negative did he come out with for his beloved shite?

It was all orchestrated to defend his team and Moaninho.

 

[discopop]

I think he was referring to whether City can maintain this level of football in those months. To be fair he said it was the best he has ever seen, at a different level. The stats are astonishing. I think he is right it's a valid question. Its a very tough time of year for the reasons he listed. And most of us on here have probably thought the same. How long can we maintain playing at this incredible level. I know I have.

I don’t mind the analysis in that regard just his inability to note that every other club will potentially suffer during the same period just the lightweights City.

 

[asahartford1]

Good analysis as usual.

With the players united have mourinho is doing well. That is the point Neville makes. Pep wouldn't be playing flowing one touch with the likes of fellaini, lokakyou, lingard and young. We are so lucky, I bet Neville is hurting though.

 

[scousemanc]

So what negative did he come out with for his beloved shite?

It was all orchestrated to defend his team and Moaninho.

He showed a video of City beating them at OT last season, which must have been painful for him. Anyway no problem with you thinking he's not a good pundit, I just happen to disagree with you.