South Park gets away with it for two main reasons I think. Firstly, Trey and Matt have been at Comedy Central since it started basically, they've been there longer than any of the executives now running it, and obviously it made its name in pushing the boundaries. Secondly, the shows aren't usually completed until the morning of the day they air. If they took months like other animated shows, law suits would shelve half of them. However, because the network doesn't know the full content until the day they air it's either play it or there's no episode. This has led the network to edit two episodes themselves before airing but obviously because they don't produce it, they can only cut things, bleep things and black things out on screen. Both episodes were to do with Muhammad. In the episodes Cartoon Wars, Muhammad was blacked out, and in South Park's 200th and the follow-on 201th episode, they blacked Muhammad out again AND censored nearly a minute of a speech in the follow-on episode - Kyle's 'I learned something today' bit. The part that is bleeped over in that episode, and that me and many others took as a joke about censorship, was not a joke. It was censorship.BlueHalli said:Im not usually a big fan of u.s comedy but their animated stuff is great. Its like there are no barriers. They can say what they like and do what they like as its 'just a cartoon'.
greasedupdeafguy said:Randy has to be the greatest cartoon character ever created
[video]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=f-JmVLEkTKc[/video]
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DT2oAtQtFrg[/video]
South park even make bleeps funny. That uncensored version is amazing as well.Skashion said:South Park gets away with it for two main reasons I think. Firstly, Trey and Matt have been at Comedy Central since it started basically, they've been there longer than any of the executives now running it, and obviously it made its name in pushing the boundaries. Secondly, the shows aren't usually completed until the morning of the day they air. If they took months like other animated shows, law suits would shelve half of them. However, because the network doesn't know the full content until the day they air it's either play it or there's no episode. This has led the network to edit two episodes themselves before airing but obviously because they don't produce it, they can only cut things, bleep things and black things out on screen. Both episodes were to do with Muhammad. In the episodes Cartoon Wars, Muhammad was blacked out, and in South Park's 200th and the follow-on 201th episode, they blacked Muhammad out again AND censored nearly a minute of a speech in the follow-on episode - Kyle's 'I learned something today' bit. The part that is bleeped over in that episode, and that me and many others took as a joke about censorship, was not a joke. It was censorship.BlueHalli said:Im not usually a big fan of u.s comedy but their animated stuff is great. Its like there are no barriers. They can say what they like and do what they like as its 'just a cartoon'.
If you want to have a listen about them talking about the Muhammad episode, see here:
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2ix3mIvBlA[/video]
The bit in the 201th episode - it's not a joke as I thought initially.
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Imj_pHXzJbc[/video]
This is the uncensored version that has been leaked onto the internet:
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mDmOGN-x0ls[/video]
Cheers Skash, hadn't seen the uncensored one before, just sent it on to a mate (ginger and loves south park) who'll love it.Skashion said:South Park gets away with it for two main reasons I think. Firstly, Trey and Matt have been at Comedy Central since it started basically, they've been there longer than any of the executives now running it, and obviously it made its name in pushing the boundaries. Secondly, the shows aren't usually completed until the morning of the day they air. If they took months like other animated shows, law suits would shelve half of them. However, because the network doesn't know the full content until the day they air it's either play it or there's no episode. This has led the network to edit two episodes themselves before airing but obviously because they don't produce it, they can only cut things, bleep things and black things out on screen. Both episodes were to do with Muhammad. In the episodes Cartoon Wars, Muhammad was blacked out, and in South Park's 200th and the follow-on 201th episode, they blacked Muhammad out again AND censored nearly a minute of a speech in the follow-on episode - Kyle's 'I learned something today' bit. The part that is bleeped over in that episode, and that me and many others took as a joke about censorship, was not a joke. It was censorship.BlueHalli said:Im not usually a big fan of u.s comedy but their animated stuff is great. Its like there are no barriers. They can say what they like and do what they like as its 'just a cartoon'.
If you want to have a listen about them talking about the Muhammad episode, see here:
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_2ix3mIvBlA[/video]
The bit in the 201th episode - it's not a joke as I thought initially.
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Imj_pHXzJbc[/video]
This is the uncensored version that has been leaked onto the internet:
[video]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mDmOGN-x0ls[/video]