gordondaviesmoustache said:JM Mcr said:GDM, I'm certainly not being disingenuous and don't think I'm being naive either (tho am feeling a tad patronised right now). If anything I would suggest that it is naive to think that teams who base their game on physicality would change that approach out if deference to another manager.
I would be happy to take you at your word about you not being disingenuous, but your subsequent comment has rendered that statement redundant in any event, as it seems to me that you are naive.
You clearly underestimate, or fail to appreciate, just how much influence a manager can have on the performance of his team not just by what he does, but also by what he doesn't do. Instead of telling Rodwell to do a 'job' on Rooney or Nani for ninety minutes, he could tell him to go out and 'express himself'. He can also set the collective tone of the team quite easily without falling into anything that looks overtly like cheating. All mangers choose their battles. It is not possible to motivate your players to the same extent in every game. To suggest otherwise is, dare I say, naive. The fact is that Moyes, at least to me, appears to reserve his blood and thunder games, where his players go all out to win and where they are fired up accordingly, for games against City and Liverpool, but not united.
Perhaps when he has a touchline argument with Ferguson or he looks like he's won the cup if his team ever gets round to beating united then I may feel different about this, but I'm not holding my breath.
This , even before factoring in the Ref..