FogBlueInSanFran
Well-Known Member
Not when hands down the best music critic in the business panned it.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
The Album Review Club - Christmas Break Until 8th January
- Thread starter RobMCFC
- Start date
Yes we raised this when we had that album didn't we. I felt exactly the same. The only comparable similarities for me were they are both skinny pointy looking dudes with odd haircuts, and with high (arguably whiny) not particularly masculine voices. Maybe the fact they like to hold their guitars a bit high. Possibly also that after a handful of good albums, both went a bit shit.Be interesting to hear your thoughts. I’ve never really got the Muse comparisons, although there clearly are for me.
But yea, beyond a crass surface level, never got the comparisons.
Like Rob I can say that I have never listened to any Radiohead album in its entirety...and after my first listen to this I can honestly say that I dont think I have missed much. Nothing grabbed me, a couple of interesting tracks but I shall give it the required 2 extra listens.
Just had this image of @FogBlueInSanFran & @threespires being backed into a corner as the mob closes in...Butch & Sundance perhaps shot down in a blaze of Paranoid Android
Just had this image of @FogBlueInSanFran & @threespires being backed into a corner as the mob closes in...Butch & Sundance perhaps shot down in a blaze of Paranoid Android
This guy?Not when hands down the best music critic in the business panned it.
Like Rob I can say that I have never listened to any Radiohead album in its entirety...and after my first listen to this I can honestly say that I dont think I have missed much. Nothing grabbed me, a couple of interesting tracks but I shall give it the required 2 extra listens.
Just had this image of @FogBlueInSanFran & @threespires being backed into a corner as the mob closes in...Butch & Sundance perhaps shot down in a blaze of Paranoid Android
At least they both know exactly why they dislike it. Which is more than can be said for many of us here at times, including me.
Their stances are not some off the cuff flippant dismissals based on momentary mood, attempting to be witty while missing the mark. And they do make for interesting discussion.
denislawsbackheel
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 28 May 2008
- Messages
- 26,277
- Team supported
- We went to Rotherham…
I didn’t understand your claim that there was a market for artistic criticism and I don’t give a rat’s arse what anyone else thinks about my tastes.Not when hands down the best music critic in the business panned it.
FogBlueInSanFran
Well-Known Member
I knew both those things already.I didn’t understand your claim that there was a market for artistic criticism and I don’t give a rat’s arse what anyone else thinks about my tastes.
BimboBob
Well-Known Member
I've never in my life taken stock of what someone who is paid to listen to an album writes about it.Not when hands down the best music critic in the business panned it.
Who cares? Trust your own judgement.
One thing I will say for this album, one listen in.
Putting aside whether it moves you or not, whether it lives up to its hype, whether it borrows, invents, is truthful or an act, and all that..
You absolutely can Not fault its delivery. Its production and execution are borderline flawless.
Its influence, even if second hand, on so many bands, many of which I happen to really like is also pretty evident and hard to argue.
Putting aside whether it moves you or not, whether it lives up to its hype, whether it borrows, invents, is truthful or an act, and all that..
You absolutely can Not fault its delivery. Its production and execution are borderline flawless.
Its influence, even if second hand, on so many bands, many of which I happen to really like is also pretty evident and hard to argue.
RobMCFC
Well-Known Member
I didn’t understand your claim that there was a market for artistic criticism and I don’t give a rat’s arse what anyone else thinks about my tastes.
I disagree with both of these comments - in the main.I've never in my life taken stock of what someone who is paid to listen to an album writes about it.
Who cares? Trust your own judgement.
I agree that in terms of how much you enjoy an album, you shouldn't give a damn what others think, especially somebody who you don't even know.
However, nobody exists in a vaccum - I find it interesting to see what other people have to say about the music I like. Not as some form of validation, but to see where there is agreement and if there are things they can point out that I may have missed.
As for music critics, they play a vital role. Nobody has time to listen to everything ever released, so why not let somebody do the filtering for you? Plus, by not reading reviews, you miss out on some witty critical putdowns.