The Album Review Club - Week #145 - (page 1923) - Tellin' Stories - The Charlatans

[Black&White&BlueMoon Town]

Amen, and after a few of the scores thus far, I may reverse my decision not to review this.

You should, assuming you can get through it. (your words, not mine! :-)

At least when I reviewed Moving Pictures and gave it a 10/10 largely on nostalgia, I spent some time taking the piss out of its ridiculous pomposity and self-indulgence, which is I think what you should at least try to do when you aren't 12 years old any more.

"This record has filler; 10/10 . . . 9/10 at LEAST." Seriously, people?

Moving Pictures comes in at a tight 40 minutes has no filler, and any perceived self-indulgence was found on prior albums, but this one came in very nicely as the band focused their sound to these gems. I'd argue they first did this the album prior on Permanent Waves, but I digress. Even the nearly 11 minute "The Camera Eye" I'd argue is the BEST song on the album. Consider your 10/10 as my MIA pile-on representation in abstentia in not being around to review it when it came up.

And am I talking about Rush so I don't have to start listening to this week's selection which BTW I have not as of yet? Maybe yes, perhaps no.

 

[mancity2012_eamo]

100% agree.

Nah! Beethoven is at least one duh! better.

 

[mancity2012_eamo]

I suppose I can now finally see why old time nostalgia picks score well.

I don’t think nostalgia is what it used to be.

 

[bennyboy]

I'd argue that Depeche Mode have had far more influence on modern music than the Roses.

I would argue though that the Stone Roses would come higher than the 85 spot on this thread.lol.

 

[threespires]

I would argue though that the Stone Roses would come higher than the 85 spot on this thread.lol.

But one look at the bottom of the list tells you that this thread, like Jon Snow, knows nothing.

 

[mancity2012_eamo]

I suppose I can now finally see why old time nostalgia picks score well.

I’m not sure you’d get away with an album like this nowadays.
It’s very much of its time. The same goes for Rick Wakeman and Henry VIII and others that went down similar routes.

 

[threespires]

This pick neatly highlights the limitation of the single answer multiple choice question. If, for instance, I wrote this question:

Jeff Wayne's War of The Worlds is....

(a) brilliant
(b) ludicrously brilliant
(c) brilliantly ludicrous
(d) ludicrous

I could possibly make a case for 3 of those answers. So where does that leave me?

 

[mancity2012_eamo]

This pick neatly highlights the limitation of the single answer multiple choice question. If, for instance, I wrote this question:

Jeff Lynne's War of The Worlds is....

(a) brilliant
(b) ludicrously brilliant
(c) brilliantly ludicrous
(d) ludicrous

I could possibly make a case for 3 of those answers. So where does that leave me?

Wayne’s World?

 

[bennyboy]

This pick neatly highlights the limitation of the single answer multiple choice question. If, for instance, I wrote this question:

Jeff Lynne's War of The Worlds is....

(a) brilliant
(b) ludicrously brilliant
(c) brilliantly ludicrous
(d) ludicrous

I could possibly make a case for 3 of those answers. So where does that leave me?

Deaf.lol.

 

[threespires]

Nah! Beethoven is at least one duh! better.

And Beethoven didn't flog the life out of his motif either, that first movement is 7 mins in total. Not sure Burton had finished clearing his throat by that point on this :-)