The Album Review Club - End of Round #9 Break (page 1904)

Was expecting downbeat slow album since my last review of songs of love and hate.
this is quite the opposite. Enjoying it.
 
My least played album of his. Could never get it and feel that it lets him down. His earlier songs are subtle, sensitive, philosophical, poetic moving and/or sexy. "Don't go home with your hard on" ? Really ?
 
Had it on in the background today rather than paying studious attention to it and it was all the better for it.
I feel the Spector treatment probably is an advantage in this mode, although I can’t really say that any song stands out. It all seems a homogeneous bland mess where the point he’s making seems lost.
There are a few different genres thrown in but I’m not sure the album is the better for them.
Fingerprints is country and western.
Hard On….. ???? Zappa is better LC….. Leave it alone.
Memories sounds like ‘It’ll be lonely this Christmas’, by Mud.

As I said I liked it better in the background, but yet to be convinced of any real merit.
 
Death of a Ladies’ Man – Leonard Cohen

My utmost respect to anybody who can listen to this more than once. This is anti-music.
  • The “music” is flat and dull, without any attempt at dynamics or anything interesting.
  • The production is awful – see above
  • The singing is OK in parts, but the horrible “let’s get 30 people all singing at once” approach is a mess.
  • Worst of all is the lyrics – My God, they are truly awful, embarrassing and in parts misogynistic.
The only positive I can find is that there is a slight uplift in tempo for the last three tracks, but again, the song are nothing to write home about. That this is from an artist capable of songs as good as “Hallelujah”, “First We Take Manhattan” and “You Want It Darker” is a bit of a mystery.

Sorry @denislawsbackheel, there is not one single element in this that I can feel positive about. I actually preferred your previous selection, The Hangman’s Beautiful Daughter – I never thought I’d say that, but this album has shown me how truly terrible music can be. 2/10.
 
Hahaha, the only anti music I've heard is rap.
This album has melody and lyrics, it's music.
Well I didn't hear any melody and I wish I hadn't heard the lyrics.

For a musician like you, Bill, who is not too slow to remind us when something's not too musical, I'm astounded at your vote for this one. But each to their own.
 
Death of a Ladies’ Man – Leonard Cohen

My utmost respect to anybody who can listen to this more than once. This is anti-music.
  • The “music” is flat and dull, without any attempt at dynamics or anything interesting.
  • The production is awful – see above
  • The singing is OK in parts, but the horrible “let’s get 30 people all singing at once” approach is a mess.
  • Worst of all is the lyrics – My God, they are truly awful, embarrassing and in parts misogynistic.
The only positive I can find is that there is a slight uplift in tempo for the last three tracks, but again, the song are nothing to write home about. That this is from an artist capable of songs as good as “Hallelujah”, “First We Take Manhattan” and “You Want It Darker” is a bit of a mystery.

Sorry @denislawsbackheel, there is not one single element in this that I can feel positive about. I actually preferred your previous selection, The Hangman’s Beautiful Daughter – I never thought I’d say that, but this album has shown me how truly terrible music can be. 2/10.
You are describing everything Phil Spector did!
 
You are describing everything Phil Spector did!
You know what, I know the name more than anything he actually did. A load of 60s Soul IIRC? Anyway, he must have had an off day/week/month when he did this. But to be fair, with the material he was given, who can blame him?
 
It’s interesting how tastes differ.
F’rinstance some of the albums on here, Zeppelin, Kiss, Genesis, Gallagher I wouldn’t have in the house. They are the antithesis of music to me.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.