The Album Review Club - Week #145 - (page 1923) - Tellin' Stories - The Charlatans

579px-Guanine_chemical_structure.png
OASIS-London-1995-Credit-Stefan-De-Batselier.jpg




surrender.jpg
Even I can take a decent stab at this one bh Chemical Brothers - Surrender
 
Haven't done a score table for a while - everybody with 20 or more votes:-

#Member#VotesTotalAvg
1BlueHammer85744806.49
2RobMCFC744766.43
3Mancitydoogle73461.56.32
4bennyboy70357.55.11
5journolud694236.13
6OB1654076.26
7GoatersLeftShin634276.78
8FogBlueInSanFran583686.34
9BimboBob562885.14
10Saddleworth2533226.08
11Coatigan503056.10
12mancity2012_eamo47308.56.56
13KnaresboroughBlue422505.95
14Bill Walker402165.40
15threespires362617.25
16manccity1332367.15
17denislawsbackheel331895.73
18GornikDaze211296.14


Hmmm, as well as wildly inconsistent I am clearly over generous. Note to self: be more Bimbo.
 
Fog, I would be interested in what you think of any of Spilt Enz earlier works. I was wondering if you decided that Waiata (which expanded on the influence Neil Finn had on Tim Finns writing on True Colours and how commercial success altered their product significantly ) made it worth your while to listen to earlier material along the lines of what Flesh and Blood may have inspired you to do likewise. We all know that time and what you do with it waits for no one but I have much of their early stuff good and bad and given your excellent time management skills I thought you might have made time to delve into some of early Split Enz earlier material.

At the risk of upsetting Rob they are well ahead of Midnight Oil in my pecking order.
I like True Colours very much but have only liked bits and pieces of their other stuff, like Frenzy and whichever it was that came after Waiata (Time and Tide I think?) but as with XTC and Mummer/Big Express, I liked individual songs on other records but not the other records on the whole as much. (I realiz(s)e this is likely to make me a pariah with XTC fans who like the stuff before and/or after those two records). I didn't cotton to Tim Finn's solo stuff at ALL, but I did like Crowded House.

As for Midnight Oil, I guess I never really put them in a pecking order -- owning one MO record and owning two SE records I guess you could say that I rank SE "higher" but that seems silly.

Sometimes when you hear a record you really love, the other stuff a band does is disappointing by comparison, so you stop exploring and cherish the record you really love; other times, a whole catalog gets opened up and the band becomes an all-timer.
 
Last edited:

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.