The Album Review Club - Week #149 - (page 1963) - Every Picture Tells A Story - Rod Stewart

[Coatigan]

On holiday mate and have limited time. Whats the deadline?

lets say 10ish tomorrow morning.

Think you've put in your top5 already. Just the guesses really.

Currently we have a fair few hide and seek champions.

 

[Saddleworth2]

Here are the results of the Amble jury.


Maybeshewill ----- GornikDaze
Iron Maiden ----- threespires
Crispian St. Peters ----- Mancitydoogle
Elton John ----- Knaresboroughblue
M.I.A. -----BimboBob
Bjork ----- GoatersLeftShin
The Black Keys -----Saddleworth2
Other Lives ----- FogBlueInSanFran
Cat Stevens ----- dennislawsbackheel
Therapy -----journolud
Brian Wilson (Smile Version) ----- RobMCFC
Bears Den -----BlueHammer85
Ryan Adams and the Cardinals ----- bennyboy
Dan Reed ----- OB1
The Neville Brothers ----- mancity1
Frightened Rabbit ----- Coatigan

 

[mancity1]

I'm taking it as people are taking it So seriously, that they are waiting till the last minute to reveal their hand.

In my case I am but I am changing my mind on at least 10 nominees even based on the detail contained in the thread to date assuming no clarkies.

I will of course meet the generous deadline given but I assume you can take until midnight today GMT before submitting a list.

 

[Coatigan]

Here are the results of the Amble jury.


Maybeshewill ----- GornikDaze
Iron Maiden ----- threespires
Crispian St. Peters ----- Mancitydoogle
Elton John ----- Knaresboroughblue
M.I.A. -----BimboBob
Bjork ----- GoatersLeftShin
The Black Keys -----Saddleworth2
Other Lives ----- FogBlueInSanFran
Cat Stevens ----- dennislawsbackheel
Therapy -----journolud
Brian Wilson (Smile Version) ----- RobMCFC
Bears Den -----BlueHammer85
Ryan Adams and the Cardinals ----- bennyboy
Dan Reed ----- OB1
The Neville Brothers ----- mancity1
Frightened Rabbit ----- Coatigan

That's busted a couple that were hiding.

Still a few remain.

@FogBlueInSanFran was the convoncing winner last time round, so on him to bust the rest.

 

[GornikDaze]

That's busted a couple that were hiding.

Still a few remain.

@FogBlueInSanFran was the convoncing winner last time round, so on him to bust the rest.

Daft question… do you include your own choice in the overall list? I’m having a senior moment!

 

[OB1]

I have a confession to make. After @OB1 chose a Kiss album on this thread I was a little sniffy and snobby about his choices. I regret that and am happy to state that I was wrong because the same poster has really switched me on to JJ Cale following his choice of Naturally which is rightly No 1 in our charts.

I am chilling on holiday with a massive compilation of Mr Cale and it is an absolute bloody joy. So here is to you @OB1 and thank you mate.

Mate, I have no problem with people being sniffy about me liking Kiss (or anything else): like you, I'm very confident in my own musical taste and appreciation.

I am delighted that you are enjoying JJ Cale.

Thank you

 

[Coatigan]

Daft question… do you include your own choice in the overall list? I’m having a senior moment!

Pretty much everyone has. You can swap it for another's, and I'll swap it back when tallying up. Or you can be clarkie-bold and leave it. Nobody will know, apart from me. In theory.

 

[OB1]

So I'm very busy at the moment and only finished my first run through of the list yesterday and have just managed a 2nd play through.

No time to play the guessing game.

Top 5

1. Madman Across the Water - Elton John
2. Under My Skin - Dan Reed
3. Busted - The Black Keys
4. Trigger Inside - Therapy
5. Crow - Bears Den

The last one was the surprise find for me.

Surf's Up would probably have made it if it was the Beach Boys version.

 

[GornikDaze]

Here’s my top 5 - although that was a struggle, this wasn’t really my cup of tea!

1 - Iron Maiden
2 - Therapy
3 - Maybeshewill
4 - Bears Den
5 - Dan Reed

As for who nominated who, I think there has been a lot of Clarkying going on, I’m sure Rob really does like Bjork ;) I think I got 2 correct last time, I’d be happy with that again!

Maybeshewill - Benny
Iron Maiden - Coatigan
Crispin St Peters - Knaresborough
Elton John - BlueHammer
Therapy - Saddleworth
Dan Reed Network - Foggy
MIA - Bimbo
Bjork - Rob
The Black Keys - OB1
Ryan Adams - Mancitydoogle
Cat Stevens - Journolud
Other Lives - Me
Brian Wilson - Mancity1
Maria McKee - Threespires
Neville Brothers - GoatersLeftShin
FR & Lau - Denis

 

[Saddleworth2]

Mate, I have no problem with people being sniffy about me liking Kiss (or anything else): like you, I'm very confident in my own musical taste and appreciation.

I am delighted that you are enjoying JJ Cale.

Thank you

Three hours of JJ the other evening with a bottle of Spanish Albariño and then a good Rioja. Mellow as a very mellow thing having a mellow turn.

I do increasingly use the list on page 1 to return to albums that I have enjoyed. Cale is the only one so far I can say has entered the mainstream although I am partial to Frightened Rabbit and Chris Whitley.

I do know what I like as Pete once said but this thread has certainly made me a great deal more open minded through the variety of music proposed.

anyway, thanks again.