roman totale
Well-Known Member
Wouldn’t go as far as saying ‘rated’, but I thought Tall Dwarfs were good. They’re the only ones I can think of off the top of my head.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
The Bluemoon Song Cup 2024 - P218 - R2/M107 - Buffalo Springfield (For What It's Worth) v Marvin Gaye (I Heard It Through The Grapevine)
- Thread starter BlueHammer85
- Start date
FogBlueInSanFran
Well-Known Member
Agreed, I very much enjoyed the Lord of the Rings trilogy as well.Wouldn’t go as far as saying ‘rated’, but I thought Tall Dwarfs were good. They’re the only ones I can think of off the top of my head.
NZBlue
Well-Known Member
has New Zealand ever produced any bands that were rated at all? :)
Not really, a few well known singers but no really big bands
I certainly don't:-)Edit: I do own that OMC thing.
LWashington
Well-Known Member
I certainly don't:-)
How BIzarre.
WickyWain
Well-Known Member
I'm not a Beach Boys fan but as it's the song cup and not the band cup, I vote for the best song and God Only Knows is a far better song.
Last edited:
hilts
Well-Known Member
Is this supposed to make posters vote for the New Zealand band New Zealand Blue? Good luck:-)Has to be the Enz.
Unfortunately the oh so bland boys have too many fanboyz on here so there will be an all too predictable result
Anyhoo God only knows why I would want to see Red.
Beach Boys for me it's a classic for a reason.
NZBlue
Well-Known Member
Not really. The outcome was predictable. What I hoped was to point out to people that the beach boys were just another harmony band- no better, no worse than many thousands of others. The problem is they read somewhere the album is a classic it must be true. Guess what, it's just another doo wap with overdubs!Is this supposed to make posters vote for the New Zealand band New Zealand Blue? Good luck:-)
OB1
Well-Known Member
Not really. The outcome was predictable. What I hoped was to point out to people that the beach boys were just another harmony band- no better, no worse than many thousands of others. The problem is they read somewhere the album is a classic it must be true. Guess what, it's just another doo wap with overdubs!
No, The Beach boys were better than other harmony bands. They wrote and sang loads of very good songs, of their type.
Good Vibrations is an astonishing single for its time. “God Only Knows” is also a bona fide classic.
I happen to agree that Pet Sounds is overrated but they were the best surf band.
hilts
Well-Known Member
I agree that pet sounds is way overrated but as a group they still made quite a few decent songs, I would say a few were great. I'm not even sure what another harmony band even means. I mean it's music is harmony a bad thing:-)Not really. The outcome was predictable. What I hoped was to point out to people that the beach boys were just another harmony band- no better, no worse than many thousands of others. The problem is they read somewhere the album is a classic it must be true. Guess what, it's just another doo wap with overdubs!
Sometimes a song is very popular because it's actually good. If they had only made one decent song which was this and every other was pure shite it wouldn't matter coz we are rating this song and this song only.
They have improved if they are dross now.I think The Beach Boys are one of the most overrated bands ever, but this is a decent-enough song and I’m also voting for it to try and stop the advancement of Split Enz, who are absolute dross.