The Bluemoon Song Cup 2024 - Round 4/M9 - P282 - The Who (Substitute) v The Bangles (Hazy Shade Of Winter)

[mancity111]

Loved the Wilson Pickett. He hasn't got the purity of Sam Cooke's soulful voice on it but his slightly gravelly take on it is fabulous. Great to hear some proper soul- Otis, Sam Cooke, Marvin, Aretha were superb but none of the modern so called soul artists can hold a candle to them.

The Pet Shop Boys on the other hand were like the Norwegian Blue- E's expired and gone to meet 'is maker

Sam is the original King of Soul and like you I presume I am old enough to remember the original when it was still played on radio and clearly best version of this song.

To think Sam Cook not Cooke left us at 33 is one of the travesties of music and of course his little piece between his legs got the better of him in the end as it has many a pop star in one way or another but that doesn't detract from his voice and song writing talents and as you say this was music you could listen to over and over again and never get tired of it.

 

[roman totale]

Wilson for me, a wonderful cover. PSB tune isn’t at all bad, but a bit too functional. It might have won out over lesser opposition.

 

[BlueHammer85]

It's a battle.

 

[hilts]

Gone for PSB especially as the Animals cover of bring it home was miles better than Wilson Pickett.

 

[JULES]

Gone for PSB especially as the Animals cover of bring it home was miles better than Wilson Pickett.

I prefer the Eddie Floyd version

 

[hilts]

I prefer the Eddie Floyd version

Takes all sorts:-)

 

[cyan]

I prefer the Eddie Floyd version

The joy of this thread is going down various wormholes and discovering lots of new versions - so I discovered that the original (Dixie) Chicks line up recorded a lovely version with just a finger-click and bass accompaniment. It's a great song and that means lots of versions are possible.

 

[NZBlue]

Sam is the original King of Soul and like you I presume I am old enough to remember the original when it was still played on radio and clearly best version of this song.

To think Sam Cook not Cooke left us at 33 is one of the travesties of music and of course his little piece between his legs got the better of him in the end as it has many a pop star in one way or another but that doesn't detract from his voice and song writing talents and as you say this was music you could listen to over and over again and never get tired of it.

I'm not actually as old as that- I had to make more of an effort to listen to the best!
Cooke does have a E though :-)

 

[BlueHammer85]

Full time whistle!
Closely fought match and Wilson Pickett brings it home. Good win.

Bring It On Home To Me 21 - 18 Always On My Mind

 

[BlueHammer85]

Get the tissues at the ready...


Rules/scores will all be on page 1.
first round only all fixtures will compete in category order.


Please click 'Like' on the song you prefer.

Round 1/CA/M 6
Category A - Cover Songs

Sinead O'Connor - Nothing Compares 2 U
V
Warren Zevon - Knockin On Heavens Door