The Bluemoon Song Cup 2024 - Semi-Final / SF/M2 / P292 - Ben E. King (Stand By Me) v The Cult (She Sells Sanctuary)

[BlueHammer85]

If this were a thread on any other English or American sporting institution's fan forum on earth, it wouldn't :)

If it was a nationwide UK vote Oasis would win, comfortably in light of their recent revival.

If it was a US vote , The Who would win.

 

[FogBlueInSanFran]

If it was a nationwide UK vote Oasis would win, comfortably.

If it was a US vote , The Who would win.

Well, I guess it will trounce The Who here then.

 

[chesterbells]

As mentioned earlier in the thread that Who performance is epic and iconic - knee slide from Pete that Rodri would be proud of.

Love the Oasis track but it ain’t even my favourite Oasis song.

The Who for me.

Yep, there are 2 or 3 Oasis tracks that for me would be genuine contenders in this match-up, but this song ain’t one of ‘em.

 

[BlueMoonRisin’]

Slide away is a good song but DGFA is very good song.
Keith Moon was one of the ever best drummers and John Entwistle is a brilliant bassist. Have a liston to the bass on this.

 

[BlueHammer85]

Well, I guess it will trounce The Who here then.

Average age on here is 76 so will make The Who favourite :)

 

[cyan]

WGFA - one of the best intros ever - leading into a great celebration of rock music. It gets my vote.

 

[BlueHammer85]

Slide away is a good song but DGFA is very good song.
Keith Moon was one of the ever best drummers and Pete Entwistle is a brilliant bassist. Have a liston to the bass on this.

Ridiculous talent, never seen a base played like that.

 

[FogBlueInSanFran]

Yep, there are 2 or 3 Oasis tracks that for me would be genuine contenders in this match-up, but this song ain’t one of ‘em.

Many big bands have hits and then "aficionado" songs -- and this seems the latter, same as "Bad" is for U2 (never released as a single, but 2nd only to "One" in fan polls).

 

[chesterbells]

Many big bands have hits and then "aficionado" songs -- and this seems the latter, same as "Bad" is for U2 (never released as a single, but 2nd only to "One" in fan polls).

I’m not sure how I’d class it really.

For me, I’d take Bring It On Down and Colombia and Little By Little as my top 3 Oasis tracks so this one just passes me by really. Doesn’t have the magic. And it’s up against one of, if not the very best, track by a worldwide colossus like The Who.

 

[blueparrot]

Don’t mind Oasis or the song, but this is nowhere near one of their best songs, and can’t touch WGFA. Mind you the videos picked don’t help it and great version of a Who performance against a mediocre and,for me,dull Oasis performance.