It made a big difference to those who got it who were away regulars, probably about 10k points, but it just meant they stayed where they are and other who got it fell behind at a slower rate as point were cut.You’re right, nobody is forced to pay, it’s a personal choice. Platinum did make a difference initially, and it still does for lots of City fans lower down the loyalty points ladder. If you add Platinum to CL, FA Cup, and Carabao cup scheme points, as a total, that makes a big difference in the increase each season on your loyalty points, and could and does make a difference to getting an away ticket or not.