Var debate 2019/20

[moon]

Foul throw how ?

If it's his feet, I think they changed the rules didn't they ?

Think the lanky Brighton defender took a throw yesterday where his feet where way over the line. So maybe right

 

[pudge]

One foot on the pitch possibly.

I doubt it but the rules are shit now so who knows

 

[Neville Kneville]

His foot was over the line and onto the pitch.

If they've changed the rules to that extent then fucking hell.

Just looked it up & it's 'part of' each foot touching or behind the line, so you can have most of your feet on the pitch.

Was any of his foot on the line ?

 

[The Light Was Yellow Sir]

I’ll have to watch again but I thought it was a penalty at first viewing. It also led to what should have been a goal so it really did need VAR.

Villa have unfairly been screwed over.

Maybe. I still think the biggest talking point should be the Newcastle goal. Exactly thane same as the goals disallowed for City and Wolves. Have they starting using the real wording of the law (in which case all 3 should have stood)?

It’s the wall of silence from all concerned that’s worrying. That and not ONE decision overturned.

 

[Bluephoria]

One foot on the pitch possibly.

Law 15 "have part of each foot on the touchline or on the ground outside the touchline" so a heel outside the line will do. Not seen the Wolves throw.

 

[SWP's back]

It wasn’t a goal as the whistle had gone. Equally, I didn’t think it was a penalty as I thought he was touched outside the box.

He was fouled twice. Pushed outside the box then had his legs taken inside.

 

[Neville Kneville]

Law 15 "have part of each foot on the touchline or on the ground outside the touchline" so a heel outside the line will do. Not seen the Wolves throw.

Yeah just read it.

I've not seen the throw in detail either.

 

[pudge]

Just looked it up & it's 'part of' each foot touching or behind the line, so you can have most of your feet on the pitch.

Was any of his foot on the line ?

What a heap of wank, half his foot is on the pitch.

Take the sidelines away then, no need for them sure.

 

[Neville Kneville]

What a heap of wank, half his foot is on the pitch.

Take the sidelines away then, no need for them sure.

No idea why they would decide to change that rule.

Because they can, probably.

 

[The Light Was Yellow Sir]

He was fouled twice. Pushed outside the box then had his legs taken inside.

Ok. Trouble is though, the way this is working, no VAR would give that. They’d not only have to overrule their colleague on the penalty but he’d have to rescind the yellow. Not happening.
Maybe they did VAR officials to only do that and not use the existing closed shop of referees?