Var debate 2019/20

Your still missing the point, the REF awarded both goals, so therefore var overturned his decision on the Liverpool goal but backed him on the United goal so var went against Liverpool

I think there's a difference between VAR disallowing for a foul, and disallowing for a handball or offside. The latter two have had goals disallowed this season.

Yesterday, there appeared to be a goal disallowed for a foul by VAR without an onfield review - the first I can remember this season (happy to be corrected).
 
If Mane’s goal had stood, nothing that happened after it would have happened in the way it did as the immediate play after it was a free kick in the United box and not a kick off from the centre spot if the goal had stood.

Everything would have been different. United could have scored from the kick off.

We have no idea if it would have been 1-2 without VAR.
Ok
 
I think there's a difference between VAR disallowing for a foul, and disallowing for a handball or offside. The latter two have had goals disallowed this season.

Yesterday, there appeared to be a goal disallowed for a foul by VAR without an onfield review - the first I can remember this season (happy to be corrected).
Fact is ref allowed both goals var disallowed one and Gave the other, all I hear on here is var is bent and wait until var and the dippers will be fucked, yet today var is great and called all decisions correct, people on here need to make their minds up, either var is corrupt or it is correct
 
I said in the pub, and I stick by it now, that if United’s goal had been disallowed by var I would have given up watching football.

Atkinson was 10 yards away from the incident with Origi, and had an uninterrupted view, so regardless of whether it was a foul or not I have no understanding of why that decision went to var to look at? Complete and utter nonsense.
All goals are checked,you don't know except the close ones that take time because it needs closer checking,the foul was within the build up
 
Is anyone else worried they'll be gifted something against Spurs now, considering the media frenzy no doubt all week over the Rashford goal???
Just like the Pen gift we weren't given yesterday after the media frenzy when Rhodri was fouled in the build-up to the Wolves goal
 
Fact is ref allowed both goals var disallowed one and Gave the other, all I hear on here is var is bent and wait until var and the dippers will be fucked yet today var is great and called all decisions correct, people on here need to make there minds up, either var is corrupt or it is correct

Fully agree with that. It's been a while, but it finally happened to Liverpool today. It may be crap, but it seems to be generally consistent.

Bar the Newcastle handball which the whole lot missed.
Potentially Alli's yesterday - I haven't seen definitive footage of where it hit him.

I think the Burnley disallowed goal yesterday was very dodgy, and not in line with how VAR has worked at any other point. It was re-reffed by VAR, and that's not meant to be how it works.
 
Mane's disallowed goal is a textbook example of a correctly disallowed goal under the new laws. It hit Mane's arm, Mane gained possession of the ball, then scored. Don't confuse it with Laporte's handball, which did not result in him gaining possession or control the ball.
 
Mane's disallowed goal is a textbook example of a correctly disallowed goal under the new laws. It hit Mane's arm, Mane gained possession of the ball, then scored. Don't confuse it with Laporte's handball, which did not result in him gaining possession or control the ball.
No one is confusing that, the fact is we have all been saying it's bent, but now today var is great and calling all.decisions correct . And making all the right calls
 
Mane's disallowed goal is a textbook example of a correctly disallowed goal under the new laws. It hit Mane's arm, Mane gained possession of the ball, then scored. Don't confuse it with Laporte's handball, which did not result in him gaining possession or control the ball.
Indeed. Seems to have been forgotten how Jesus’ goal should have stood as Laporte did not gain control or possession of the ball after it struck his arm.
 

Don't have an account? Register now and see fewer ads!

SIGN UP
Back
Top
  AdBlock Detected
Bluemoon relies on advertising to pay our hosting fees. Please support the site by disabling your ad blocking software to help keep the forum sustainable. Thanks.