meltonblue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 14 May 2013
- Messages
- 6,250
I didn’t think the penalty decision was a VAR problem tbh, I thought it was entirely a Michael Oliver issue. The moment he didn’t give it, VAR wasn’t going to overturn it.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Var debate 2019/20
- Thread starter Chi-town blues
- Start date
kaz7
Well-Known Member
That's not true anymore,the last 2/3 rounds of games var has overuled several refs,it's a change brought in without any explanationI didn’t think the penalty decision was a VAR problem tbh, I thought it was entirely a Michael Oliver issue. The moment he didn’t give it, VAR wasn’t going to overturn it.
Rammy Blue
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 23 May 2008
- Messages
- 29,853
I’ve said it numerous times, but it gets lost in the thread, but all of this could be put to bed very simply by an accurate VAR being done and shown to all of us around the world.The second Salah goal wasn’t checked by VAR.
The Hawkeye operator takes a set amount of time to set up the review for the Video Assistant Referee to look at - its an absolute fact that this couldn’t have happened within the timeframe it did.
Forget the penalty - this is the scandal.
The goal wasn’t reviewed, the only question is why it wasn’t.
Where is it?
super_city_si
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Dec 2007
- Messages
- 45,528
you and a lot of people mate. I'm convinced it was offside and until I see proof (not the bullshit sky still) I will believe we've been done.I’ve said it numerous times, but it gets lost in the thread, but all of this could be put to bed very simply by an accurate VAR being done and shown to all of us around the world.
Where is it?
It overruled him at home when we played spursI didn’t think the penalty decision was a VAR problem tbh, I thought it was entirely a Michael Oliver issue. The moment he didn’t give it, VAR wasn’t going to overturn it.
VAR does not remove human judgements, decisions or errors. It is fundamentally flawed. Simple case in point is some human has to decide what frame at what point to base a decision on. 3 arbitrary decisions open to interpretation and corruption. It was the emperor’s new clothes and some of you are still defending itI’ve said it numerous times, but it gets lost in the thread, but all of this could be put to bed very simply by an accurate VAR being done and shown to all of us around the world.
Where is it?
The second Salah goal wasn’t checked by VAR.
The Hawkeye operator takes a set amount of time to set up the review for the Video Assistant Referee to look at - its an absolute fact that this couldn’t have happened within the timeframe it did.
Forget the penalty - this is the scandal.
The goal wasn’t reviewed, the only question is why it wasn’t.
Yep. The (non-)penalty decision has actually become a pretty useful smokescreen behind which they can hide the bigger scandal.
Pingu the Penguin
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 29 Sep 2009
- Messages
- 7,036
VAR does not remove human judgements, decisions or errors. It is fundamentally flawed. Simple case in point is some human has to decide what frame at what point to base a decision on. 3 arbitrary decisions open to interpretation and corruption. It was the emperor’s new clothes and some of you are still defending it
Absolutely this. Sold to us on the basis it would right obvious wrongs, etc. Anyone who thinks the TAA handball wasn’t handball is seriously deluded but the subjectivity gives licence to them.
I’ve said it numerous times, but it gets lost in the thread, but all of this could be put to bed very simply by an accurate VAR being done and shown to all of us around the world.
Where is it?
The offside wasn’t checked.
samarasra
Well-Known Member
So am I. The fact that Sky didn't do their usual non stop replays of it is very suspicious.you and a lot of people mate. I'm convinced it was offside and until I see proof (not the bullshit sky still) I will believe we've been done.