What City player was most over rated by our own fans

[blueunit]

Sad to say it as he is a legend but for me its Shaun Wright Phillips when he came back form Chelsea.

Just was not the same player.

 

[Pigeonho]

Sad to say it as he is a legend but for me its Shaun Wright Phillips when he came back form Chelsea.

Just was not the same player.

Nobody overrated him in his second spell.

 

[chorltonblue]

Zabaleta. Love him but he's not as good as some on here make out.

shut up

 

[Pigeonho]

Zabaleta. Love him but he's not as good as some on here make out.

shut up

I think you just got Ono'd.

 

[chorltonblue]

can't believe people are saying kinky.

you're fucking nuts.

+1

 

[6one]

Zabaleta. Love him but he's not as good as some on here make out.

Clueless. Nothing more needs to be said.

-- Tue Aug 06, 2013 3:50 am --

add zabaleta to the list.

M. Johnson
A. Johnson
C. Tevez
G. Kinkladze.
Paul Lake.

Paul Lake, Tevez, Zabaleta and Kinkladze... Dear oh dear. Think i might go to bed now.

I know. By the way, I'd have staked my life on old Mr 6one being a newbie with less than 100 posts, so I went back and checked, and sure enough! 3 letter word, begins with 'r', ends in 'g'.......

Not a rag. 17 years season ticket holder.

I included Paul Lake. Bit of a funny one. It never materialised how good he was or not because of his injury, so nobody knows how good or not he may have been. So we don't know. But people say as though it's certain he'd have been England captain etc...

Tevez I think was massively overrated, and much like Suarez he is to the detriment of the team in my opinion. With their greediness and excessive touches of the ball. It was no coincidence in my mind that when Tevez came back into the team last season, we were less prolific than in 11/12 and like we were in 10/11 again when Tevez was the main man. Tevez was also obsessed with being the main man, and when he felt he wasn't he wanted to leave. He only came back to collect his money and when he did come back, he was not as good as he was before his sabbatical.

Adam Johnson was very useful in 11/12 and could have done with some of his goals last year, but he was overrated, as shown by his poor season at Sunderland. Should do better this year though now his stock has reduced.

Kinkladze, to hear some talk it's like the guy was messi. if he was that good, he'd have single handedly stopped the club being relegated.

Michael Johnson is overrated to the extent that you're only as good as you treat your body (see Rooney) and people were too quick to give excuses for Johnson. His lifestyle was atrocious for an "athlete" especially one on £30,000 a week and contributed to his weighty frame. People even made the excuse saying that it was the medication that made him balloon. That doesn't wash.

 

[The Flash]

Zabaleta. Love him but he's not as good as some on here make out.

shut up

I think you just got Ono'd.

Onooooooo!

 

[Lucky Toma]

Elano. Was given far too much leeway by Blues because admittedly he had god-given talent to spare.

But a lazy twat is still a lazy twat.

 

[Skashion]

I'm very amused by those who still have a lingering bitterness towards Balotelli.

 

[citysince88]

Looking back, the Rolls Royce of a defender Vedran Corluka. Remember the frustration when he was sold then a few weeks later the soldier named Zabaleta rocked up.

Vedran was a good long range passer and that was about it.