Most of The Beatles stuff after their mop top period was better than their earlier stuff. Oasis first album was their best and then it got poorer.citykev28 said:PaulPowerShower said:Erm.....whatever you want mate.....I said they didnt do anything I thought was as good as def maybe....you implied I called the beatles shite....very odd comment to make
no, i'm comparing the beatles. in a lot of people's opinions, the beatles best stuff was the early stuff so to dismiss the rest is daft. i never said you commented on the beatles but you did say you didn't listen to oasis after 1st album because none of it was as good. how do you know if you didn't listen? i said that no band has made an album as good since definitley maybe so should we discard all music from the last 15 years?
Abe Froman said:And your four others are?citykev28 said:bollocks
Who rattled your cage? lolcitykev28 said:Abe Froman said:And your four others are?
that would be funny if i hadn't already posted on page 2. check full thread before being a comedian / smart-arse.
Abe Froman said:Most of The Beatles stuff after their mop top period was better than their earlier stuff. Oasis first album was their best and then it got poorer.citykev28 said:no, i'm comparing the beatles. in a lot of people's opinions, the beatles best stuff was the early stuff so to dismiss the rest is daft. i never said you commented on the beatles but you did say you didn't listen to oasis after 1st album because none of it was as good. how do you know if you didn't listen? i said that no band has made an album as good since definitley maybe so should we discard all music from the last 15 years?
Loved Definitely Maybe and still play it often.
Casual Beatle fans prefer their early stuff whereas a real Beatle fan knows the score.citykev28 said:Abe Froman said:Most of The Beatles stuff after their mop top period was better than their earlier stuff. Oasis first album was their best and then it got poorer.
Loved Definitely Maybe and still play it often.
i'm saying that in a lot of people's opinion, the beatles early stuff was their best. it's your opinion that the later stuff was better. does that mean the early stuff should be shunned? i personally think people who slag oasis off, nine times out of ten don't know what they are talking about. it became fashionable to slag them after 'be here now'.
After Definitely Maybe, really. Everyone's got their own taste, Oasis aren't mine and I own every album. Just think that there's a lot better out there. Even Blur were better than Oasis in my opinion of course.citykev28 said:Abe Froman said:Most of The Beatles stuff after their mop top period was better than their earlier stuff. Oasis first album was their best and then it got poorer.
Loved Definitely Maybe and still play it often.
i'm saying that in a lot of people's opinion, the beatles early stuff was their best. it's your opinion that the later stuff was better. does that mean the early stuff should be shunned? i personally think people who slag oasis off, nine times out of ten don't know what they are talking about. it became fashionable to slag them after 'be here now'.
Abe Froman said:Casual Beatle fans prefer their early stuff whereas a real Beatle fan knows the score.citykev28 said:i'm saying that in a lot of people's opinion, the beatles early stuff was their best. it's your opinion that the later stuff was better. does that mean the early stuff should be shunned? i personally think people who slag oasis off, nine times out of ten don't know what they are talking about. it became fashionable to slag them after 'be here now'.
Oasis did go shit before Be Her Now and it's a fact.
If you like them then so be it. No need to go defensive.
Why?citykev28 said:the oasis slaggers rattle my cage every time pal. i will defend them 'til my dying day, i swear it by my own blood. ;o)
my first row on here was with a bloke in america slagging our liam. ended up a bit nasty and we had to pm each other to sort it out.
Abe Froman said:Why?citykev28 said:the oasis slaggers rattle my cage every time pal. i will defend them 'til my dying day, i swear it by my own blood. ;o)
my first row on here was with a bloke in america slagging our liam. ended up a bit nasty and we had to pm each other to sort it out.
It's only music and not exactly great songwriting/vocals or even musicianship.