Alan Harper's Tash
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 12 Dec 2010
- Messages
- 50,326
Danny Tiato's wonder goal at Middlesbrough
Why would VAR help there when spurs are obviously exempt from rules like offside and violent conduct?All of spurs offside goals
Blues are kidding yourselves if you think VAR will help us. Why would it when the current post match referal system already stitches us up?
Edin’s equaliser would probably have been cancelled out for Kompany’s foul at the corner...Sergio’s goal against QPR.
Brought back for a penalty for the foul on Mario.
Crosby ‘goal’ at Forest.
Well, last season and the one before that were awful for City in terms of refereeing decisions. Both games against Tottenham in Pellegrini's last season, games against Spurs, Liverpool and Arsenal thrown by poor choices.
This season there have only been two standout decisions in games we haven't won.
1) Walker's sending off vs Everton. This was absurd and a clear mistake by Madley, who just isn't up to PL standard. Would we have won that game if he'd stayed on the pitch? Maybe, but we were 1-0 down and played far better after the sending off anyway.
2) Zaha penalty win for Sterling's 'foul' against Palace. This was also extremely soft. If it hadn't been given, what would've happened? We might've scored in the last few minutes but we were so awful that day that it doesn't seem likely.
Personally I don't think Firmino fouled Stones. I think we're getting fair treatment this season.
Well, last season and the one before that were awful for City in terms of refereeing decisions. Both games against Tottenham in Pellegrini's last season, games against Spurs, Liverpool and Arsenal thrown by poor choices.
This season there have only been two standout decisions in games we haven't won.
1) Walker's sending off vs Everton. This was absurd and a clear mistake by Madley, who just isn't up to PL standard. Would we have won that game if he'd stayed on the pitch? Maybe, but we were 1-0 down and played far better after the sending off anyway.
2) Zaha penalty win for Sterling's 'foul' against Palace. This was also extremely soft. If it hadn't been given, what would've happened? We might've scored in the last few minutes but we were so awful that day that it doesn't seem likely.
Personally I don't think Firmino fouled Stones. I think we're getting fair treatment this season.
Well, last season and the one before that were awful for City in terms of refereeing decisions. Both games against Tottenham in Pellegrini's last season, games against Spurs, Liverpool and Arsenal thrown by poor choices.
This season there have only been two standout decisions in games we haven't won.
1) Walker's sending off vs Everton. This was absurd and a clear mistake by Madley, who just isn't up to PL standard. Would we have won that game if he'd stayed on the pitch? Maybe, but we were 1-0 down and played far better after the sending off anyway.
2) Zaha penalty win for Sterling's 'foul' against Palace. This was also extremely soft. If it hadn't been given, what would've happened? We might've scored in the last few minutes but we were so awful that day that it doesn't seem likely.
Personally I don't think Firmino fouled Stones. I think we're getting fair treatment this season.
Still the single most dodgy thing I’ve seen in English football.David Luis non-sending off for bringing down Kun last season.
The whole league season may have been completely different had they gone down to 10 men at that point.