Sheikh n Bake
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- 7 Sep 2005
- Messages
- 1,837
Stone Roses, definitely
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Stone Roses or The Smiths?
- Thread starter The Oracle
- Start date
The Oracle
Well-Known Member
when was the last time you listened to either album?TheMightyQuinn said:The Oracle said:yeah, but I'm talking about which one album is the best.TheMightyQuinn said:The Smiths though I do love the Roses too but when you get right down to the nitty gritty and look at it man for man then it's 3-1 Smiths (Reni scoring for the Roses) plus the roses had one decent album, half decent album and a few good singles. The Smiths had 4 top albums, singles and b sides that to this day havent been matched and the lyrics of little Moz.
The Smiths were more consistent but no album they made could top 'The Stone Roses'
Ah I see where you're coming from here and it's an interesting point.
Meat Is Murder Vs The Stone Roses?
I'd probably give you an honest but different answer every day!
My favourite music is classic blues and soul and r'n'b but I haven't listened to The Smiths in years but I just played 'The Stone Roses' through again.
guv
Well-Known Member
Best album - The Stone Roses
Best catalogue - The Smiths
So, I suppose I'd rather have several good albums than one great album.
The Smiths.
Edit:
Oh, it's an album choice?
My favourite Smiths' album is Meat Is Murder, but The Stone Roses is far, far better. Even though MIM is amazing.
Best catalogue - The Smiths
So, I suppose I'd rather have several good albums than one great album.
The Smiths.
Edit:
Oh, it's an album choice?
My favourite Smiths' album is Meat Is Murder, but The Stone Roses is far, far better. Even though MIM is amazing.
Tell The King
Well-Known Member
The Smiths, the melodies, the lyrics. i don't know, they inspire me more than the stone roses.
TheMightyQuinn
Well-Known Member
The Oracle said:when was the last time you listened to either album?TheMightyQuinn said:The Oracle said:yeah, but I'm talking about which one album is the best.TheMightyQuinn said:The Smiths though I do love the Roses too but when you get right down to the nitty gritty and look at it man for man then it's 3-1 Smiths (Reni scoring for the Roses) plus the roses had one decent album, half decent album and a few good singles. The Smiths had 4 top albums, singles and b sides that to this day havent been matched and the lyrics of little Moz.
The Smiths were more consistent but no album they made could top 'The Stone Roses'
Ah I see where you're coming from here and it's an interesting point.
Meat Is Murder Vs The Stone Roses?
I'd probably give you an honest but different answer every day!
My favourite music is classic blues and soul and r'n'b but I haven't listened to The Smiths in years but I just played 'The Stone Roses' through again.
Meat Is Murder probably a few weeks back in its entirity, Roses probably a few months back.
The Fat el Hombre
Well-Known Member
Big big fan of both fans but gotta be The Smiths for me
MCFCTrick
Well-Known Member
The Stone Roses by a mile for me. Their debut wil be in my all-time top ten forever.
jimharri
Moderator
Exactly BT. Couldn't have put it better myself. I wouldn't be that gone on either of them. Then again, I would prefer the sound of fingernails being scraped down a blackboard to the Smiths!!BTâ„¢ said:I'm not keen on either but The Stone Roses just.
stonerblue
Well-Known Member
guv said:Best album - The Stone Roses
Best catalogue - The Smiths
So, I suppose I'd rather have several good albums than one great album.
The Smiths.
Edit:
Oh, it's an album choice?
My favourite Smiths' album is Meat Is Murder, but The Stone Roses is far, far better. Even though MIM is amazing.
what he said only with 'strangeways' as best Smiths album